I don't understand all the hate for Vickers...
I loved Shaw...she was a strong character, but did everyone just forget what a tragic character Vickers was?
She was an antagonist to be sure, but she was is a position of being rejected by her own father in favor of an artificial "son"
Did everybody just forget that Weyland said straight out - I never had a son and David is the closest I have to a son -- the implication is that he undervalued his daughter...
Vickers in a way is symbolic of the Succesor never replacing the King and his reign...The father creates 2 children, Vickers and David - one who is in favor and the other not.
Just like the Engineers created us and will not allow us to succeed it -- wants to terminate us but we don't know why...
To say those who prefer Vickers over Shaw is shallow, is akin to saying those who prefer Han to Luke is Shallow...(and Han was a minor antagonist-turned co-protagonist)...
I like Vickers and thought her role was interesting and lent a different dimension to Weyland as a person -- why did he prefer his "artifical son" to her? Was it because she is a female? Was there an element of sexism that caused him to in a way reject his daughter?
The people who dislike Vickers so much may have missed the point...
I'm not saying Shaw is worse -- I like her -- takes a strong character to do what she did to survive...
But as a guy, I wouldn't mind seeing Vickers as a figure -- call me shallow, but she's an attractive woman and makes a good-looking figure. I wouldn't want my Batman figures to be less than heroic or good-looking either...it's natural to like looking at what's attractive -- nothing shallow about that -- I"m not saying attractive people are better -- I'm stating a fact that things that're well assembled, painted, put-together, built, drawn, design, etc are just pleasant to look at...period...
And of course the exterior should never be thought of to be indicative of the interior...I don't judge a book by its cover, I judge a book by what its content...I don't even judge it by how the content is worded...because logic is in the language and we all have different ways of saying similar things.
now, that said, the way a film "paints" the characters are important to me and I like the way Vickers' character was painted -- she was tragic, yes, but it makes me feel bad for her. I thought toward the end she was sympathetic...but had to die b/c she no longer served a dramatic purpose.
There was a large enough dimension to the main characters, aside from the red-shirts in my opinion...(well I guess ultimately all were red shirts except David and Shaw, right?) - scratch that last comment! ;P