Centrocal
Super Freak
HI RES pg 5 post# 41
Boy, really have to disagree, there. Perhaps that was true of Star Wars but Lucas certainly understood the marketing potential for figures by ESB and ROTJ. He's been criticized pretty roundly for letting marketing dictate the fate of characters like Han Solo in ROTJ (wouldn't let him die as it'd be a downer for figure sales... think it was Kasden or someone close to the process that said that). Regardless, I'm just happy as a fan of the franchise that Disney did get it out of Lucas' hands, so we can hopefully get good movies again. $3B is a lot for Disney to make back, so I wish them well....Lucas designed everything to look and flow together like they belonged. He had nobody to answer to. His designs were made for a movie portraying his vision and story, not for the purpose of selling toys/action figures...
Boy, really have to disagree, there. Perhaps that was true of Star Wars but Lucas certainly understood the marketing potential for figures by ESB and ROTJ. He's been criticized pretty roundly for letting marketing dictate the fate of characters like Han Solo in ROTJ (wouldn't let him die as it'd be a downer for figure sales... think it was Kasden or someone close to the process that said that). Regardless, I'm just happy as a fan of the franchise that Disney did get it out of Lucas' hands, so we can hopefully get good movies again. $3B is a lot for Disney to make back, so I wish them well.
I think Gary Kurtz said in an article that ROTJ was driven by what George thought would sell as a toy. That's why they went their separate ways after making the OT?
Did ‘Star Wars’ become a toy story? Producer Gary Kurtz looks back [Updated] | Hero Complex – movies, comics, pop culture – Los Angeles Times
I’m not that dubious about JJ/Disney’s motives for making all these trooper variants. To me, it just seems like a great opportunity to create this new army with all the sub-departments or what have you. They had a healthy budget to create this new world, why not use it? Lucas’s motives for only doing slight variations between troopers may have been driven by the very tight budget they had. Like you said, it was cheaper to re-use parts from other troopers than it would have been to create new ones from scratch. As far as trooper variations for the Prequels, there weren’t that many different types of troopers onscreen, were there? Not like how we’re seeing very specific situations here like snow troopers and flame troopers? I know the bomb squadron prequel trooper has a distinct helmet, doesn’t he?
This turned into "First World Problems: The Thread".
Some people are just permanently stuck in the OT nostalgia time warp and will never enjoy new things.
Well that's what I want. Variety. There's so much of it in that image you posted. You don't get that with this Flametrooper.Except the link with the German Army is undeniable and the German Army like any other has different classes of soldiers with differing uniforms. They even had a Flame-thrower (Flammenwerfer) Division - the Garde Reserve Pionier Regiment or “Deathshead Pioniers”.
You could just refer to all the soldiers as troopers, but they all had different training, skill sets, purposes and uniforms to boot.
If we look at the OT as WWI German Troopers and Ep VII etc as WWII - we should be Thankful there aren't more variants - as we'd all be flat broke.
WWII for eg.
Exactly, I can't imagine how a guy with a flamethrower is going to take down a regular trooper grunt with a blaster.I never understood why an army with laser guns etc. needed good old fashioned flame throwers but we'll find out. Looks super cool and likely a purchase....it's a trooper..don't need to see the film to decide whether to buy or not as their all back ground characters.
Well that's what I want. Variety. There's so much of it in that image you posted. You don't get that with this Flametrooper.
I was hoping we'd see the kind of variety we saw in the PT:
Exactly, I can't imagine how a guy with a flamethrower is going to take down a regular trooper grunt with a blaster.
I think the whole idea of a Flametrooper seems redundant, but if it's going to be a thing it could at least have more features to differentiate itself from the other troopers.
That's true, but that's not going to change this guy's or the heavy trooper's current designs.How does a trooper with a laser gun burn down a whole village to terrorize them? You're also highlighting PT troopers from one movie to highlight all the variety. There were none in the first, only two types in the second.
Enter your email address to join: