Given the new design a lot of thought. I love the OT armour and always will, but the changes they made for Rogue One go further in selling these guys as armoured grunts that can actually fight. The breastplate is narrower to accomodate weapon-handling, the lenses are maybe a bit more plausible for better vision, the leg armour allows greater mobility...the design is growing on me.
As Talibane mentioned, Hot Toys initially looked *twice removed* from the source material (I think we actually discussed this well before the film came out) -- because the re-design was different enough from the OT, and then their sculpt was just a touch softer than what we saw in RO trailers and stills.
Having seen the film twice, I can separate the variances in my head and so far, the HT Rogue One sculpt looks more accurate to that film, than the ANH sculpt does to its respective movie. When properly futzed, I don't see the RO figures looking overly awkward.
I like 'em both, so far...
Yeah but the ANH stormtroopers we got were based off the hero trooper, not the much more widely seen stunt trooper. So a lot of the variance sits right there. Not saying they were perfect, I was calling the helmet as off from the first promo shot, but the Sandtrooper based off the stunt was a lot better.
Though it is hard to say because RO was the singularly WORST treatment of stormies as thoroughly useless "armored" soldiers - even worse than Ewok arrows. They were in essence dummies that waited to be shot or clubbed to death with a little baton wielded by a small-framed woman, or a stick wielded by a blind man. This was one element that at times took me out of the narrative it was so utterly ridiculous.
Totally disagree. RO finally made stormtroopers into the feared death squads ANH said they were. They completely minced the rebels on Scarriff. And don't forget Jyn was basically trained as a freedom fighter by someone even the rebels considered too extreme, and Chirrut was force sensitive and clearly knew his way around a staff in a fight. Heck he shot down Tie Fighters with a blaster with such precision the crash took out a battery emplacement.