thxr1088
Just a little freaky
- Joined
- Jan 5, 2016
- Messages
- 7
- Reaction score
- 0
Is that on the normal TFA Luke body? Right arm looks a bit short.
Yes
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Is that on the normal TFA Luke body? Right arm looks a bit short.
Some of you asked for..
With brown glove on
Side by side comparison
Painting TFA > TLJ
Likeness TLJ > TFA
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Is that on the normal TFA Luke body? Right arm looks a bit short.
You'd kind of think a "I'm heading out to burn a tree" outfit would be more like his normal dirty outfit plus gas can.
It's hard to understand what that even means though as because - as I understand it - the tree itself is nothing but a hollowed out old tree, ie the tree itself is not significant (ie this tree was not some kind of "Jedi library" of the distant past). And the books in it were books that Luke himself assembled over time - I assume in his travels - and then put into the tree when he arrived, he didn't find them there. Why he chose to store them in an old tree instead of in his hut is unclear.
So I guess this "I'm burning the tree down" thing is kind of odd given that it's simply an old tree (albeit on a historically significant island) and he could just take the books out and do whatever he wants with them. It's a bit like storing the Magna Carta in a garden shed and then dramatically saying "I'm going to burn down the garden shed".
Dude, they’re all just movies. No sequel is gonna live up to your imaginary version caked in nostalgia filters“They’re just movies” I completely agree. TFA and TLJ are just movies, and there’s my issue with these films in a nutshell. We deserved better. I waited 39 years to see a sequel worthy of the original Star Wars legendary films. I’m still waiting.
View attachment 434963
Luke intended to end the Jedi where their earliest roots had been, and where the sacred texts were meant to be. He seems to still have enough reverence for the Jedi to want to do it all with respect and ceremonial dignity. That's what I take away from him wearing the Jedi outfit, and from wanting to burn the books in their sacred holding place (as opposed to taking them somewhere random). I think the movie (and novelization) gives the tree library a clearly symbolic, as well as practical, significance to both Luke's intentions and the Jedi Order itself.
Dude, they’re all just movies. No sequel is gonna live up to your imaginary version caked in nostalgia filters
Some of you asked for..
With brown glove on
Side by side comparison
Painting TFA > TLJ
Likeness TLJ > TFA
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Yeah, nice work ajp.
Any word on why books though? There's not a single other book, pen or piece of paper in the whole saga to my recollection.
Switching the head sculpt back and forth between TFA and TLJ in this few days, just don’t know why, I still think this is the best combination. TFA head on TLJ body is way better than stock version.
Yeah it looks way too dark to me as well. Unless you're going for his look in one of the rainy island scenes. Lol
That actually looks better to me too. It’s weird as the TFA sculpt looks off on the TFA figure, but looks good on the TLJ figure. I think the TLJ sculpt is technically better, but the hair is too dark.Switching the head sculpt back and forth between TFA and TLJ in this few days, just don’t know why, I still think this is the best combination. TFA head on TLJ body is way better than stock version.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Switching the head sculpt back and forth between TFA and TLJ in this few days, just don’t know why, I still think this is the best combination. TFA head on TLJ body is way better than stock version.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
That actually looks better to me too. It’s weird as the TFA sculpt looks off on the TFA figure, but looks good on the TLJ figure. I think the TLJ sculpt is technically better, but the hair is too dark.
Not only does TLJ have the only book(s) that I can recall being in the cinematic saga, it doubled down by having the only pen too. The pen is in the flashback scenes next to Ben's lightsaber. Outside of being a visual metaphor for "the pen is mightier than the sword" (even a laser sword), I have no idea why it was shown in Ben Solo's hut. It was prominent enough to likely have some purpose, though.
Coincidentally, the only other handwriting reference in any SW story that I can remember is a recent one as well. In the "Bloodline" novel (set 6 years prior to TFA), Leia discovers a handwritten note telling her to run. Because of it, she managed to escape from a bomb that went off in the Senate. I doubt that the note has any connection at all to Ben's pen in TLJ, but handwriting seems to be a novelty now in these new SW stories.
As for why books were chosen, I can only speculate. My best guess has to do with the PT Jedi library that Khev referenced. Once Lucas established that the PT-era Jedi Temple had a library, Johnson may have wanted to root that concept to the very first Jedi Temple. Seeing as how the Ahch-To one predated the Coruscant one by thousands of years, perhaps books seemed like an appropriate way to represent a more archaic form of the digital data files seen on the shelves in the PT.
Either way, I was glad to see a Jedi library in the prequels (and also used a handful of times in the Clone Wars series) because it attaches a scholarly component to being a Jedi. It's not just about acquiring skills like levitating and sword fighting, it's just as much about acquiring knowledge. I like that! The TLJ library is more spiritual than scholastic, but I appreciate the foundation of knowledge being key to the Jedi religion/way.
The tree's significance is actually made explicitly clear in the movie. When Rey tells Luke that she'd seen that place before in dreams, Luke tells her that it was built a thousand generations earlier in order to house the first Jedi texts. It's not just a random tree that was hollowed out. It had a very specific (and sacred) design/purpose. Not only was the library built during the origins of the Jedi for that sacred purpose, but it was significant enough for Rey to have seen it in her dreams. Here's the bit of dialogue as presented in the TLJ novelization:
View attachment 434964
Luke's reason for being on that island, and how it relates to the tree library, is made even more explicitly clear on the next page. Here's part of that page, still from the scene with Rey and Luke in the tree library (I underlined the relevant section):
View attachment 434963
Luke intended to end the Jedi where their earliest roots had been, and where the sacred texts were meant to be. He seems to still have enough reverence for the Jedi to want to do it all with respect and ceremonial dignity. That's what I take away from him wearing the Jedi outfit, and from wanting to burn the books in their sacred holding place (as opposed to taking them somewhere random). I think the movie (and novelization) gives the tree library a clearly symbolic, as well as practical, significance to both Luke's intentions and the Jedi Order itself.
Enter your email address to join: