I think the show is great, but at times it feels too familiar and I wonder why I am not just playing the game instead.
I get that. But, when the game adaptations start to deviate from the games to be different or original, they've basically already lost IMO. We've seen it time and time again and it just doesn't tend to work for general audience nor the gamers. Then you see the many comments that say something like "just make the movie (or show in this case) like the game!" which is nearly exactly what HBO has done here and it seems to be working.
Just look at Uncharted. Even with starting with a younger Drake, they still probably could've just went ahead and made Drake's Fortune and followed the natural story telling of the games with some tweaks here and there. Instead, they basically started off with elements of UC3 and mashed them with their own story, plus they added in Sam who we don't actually see until UC4, if I remember correctly. That movie was awful just as the many video game adaptations before it b/c of the deviation from the games.
As for TLOU show, I'm still not on board with their change of no spores, but, fortunately, the rest is good enough so far so I guess it's fine.
And to stay on topic of this thread, the show continues to make the want for these original game figures to grow more and more. Sure, I'd like some of live action versions eventually, but we definitely need quality ones from the game first and foremost. And Lim seems to be up to the task based on what we’ve heard so far