LOST discussion - thar be spoilers ahead!

Collector Freaks Forum

Help Support Collector Freaks Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Quick question:

What us the general consensus on who Christian was in the well when Locke was pushing the donkey wheel and said "Say hi to my son."? Was it really Jack's dad or was it TMIB?
 
What us the general consensus on who Christian was in the well when Locke was pushing the donkey wheel and said "Say hi to my son."? Was it really Jack's dad or was it TMIB?

Yeah, MIB. He mentioned his son to get Locke to talk to Jack, which would influence Jack to come back.

We never did find out why Christian's coffin was empty, did we??
 
Last edited:
Quick question:

What us the general consensus on who Christian was in the well when Locke was pushing the donkey wheel and said "Say hi to my son."? Was it really Jack's dad or was it TMIB?

I think it had to be MIB. Wasn't that the scene where he tells Locke he needs to "sacrifice" (meaning die)? Can't remember the specific dialogue.
I'm curious if they will ever get specific about Christian Shephard. The only time I am absolutely sure he was not MIB (aside from flashbacks and the final scene) was when Jack sees him in the USA after he's off the island.
I need a rewatch....
 
Yeah, MIB. He mentioned his son to get Locke to talk to Jack, which would influence Jack to come back.

We never did find out why Christian's coffin was empty, did we??

But did Locke ever play that card to Jack? I don't remember him ever mentioning that event to him. If I recall coorectly he didn't even know who Christian's son was.
 
But did Locke ever play that card to Jack? I don't remember him ever mentioning that event to him. If I recall coorectly he didn't even know who Christian's son was.

Yes, he did. In "The Life And Death of Jeremy Bentham", when Locke wakes up in Jack's hospital. He says he met a man and he ruled the man out as Sayid and Hurley's father.
 
Oh ok. I don't recall that scene. Thanks. That was one strand which has been nagging around the back of my head. :)
 
Yeah, it's here if you need a refresher, seek to 32:30.

Lostpedia put the pieces together for me, as that ep took place in the timeline earlier than Jack's flashforward from Season 4. So it explains why Jack is belligerent at the hospital and he's shouting to bring his father down here.
 
I don't get it. How is this different than the soundtracks that have been released so far?

Is it like a "best of" the 6 seasons or what?
 
Its different in that it is music scored for the final season. In other words, yes, it has different music.
 

Well seeing as I said "RELEASED TODAY" and your first link was released today and your second was released March 21, 2006 I am pretty sure I am referring to the first link you posted. :slap

*Yes I am in a snarky mood today* :mad:
 
Well seeing as I said "RELEASED TODAY" and your first link was released today and your second was released March 21, 2006 I am pretty sure I am referring to the first link you posted. :slap


This is the first link I posted:

^^^That's the link you said "yup"to. Am I to take it to mean that you were being sarcastic with your "yup"? [You said you were resisting sarcasm.]

Here I thought you were being helpful and honest.




*Yes I am in a snarky mood today* :mad:
:nana:
 
Are you really this dense?

You FIRST link (ie the one that says "THE FINAL SEASON"):


Your SECOND link:




Clear?

Yay! :hi5:
 
Back
Top