Solo: A Star Wars Story

Collector Freaks Forum

Help Support Collector Freaks Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Re: Solo: A Star Wars Story (May 25th, 2018)

Seems like they are fudged either way.

Either he portrays Han just how he is in the OT and then it's nothing but scrutiny and criticism for how "off" it is or they present him totally different and have a character arc that brings him around to the OT Han, but their track record with character arcs are pretty weak so far.

:exactly:

Hence, why there's a group that wish this project had never been green lit, to me it goes beyond whether this movie is good or not, or whether people can accept this version of Han. I think the trailer looks fine, but wish these were all different characters. To me it signals that Lucasfilm will just milk the heroes, the names we all know, as they're too interested on cashing in.

Ultimately I suspect it means they'll be willing to eventually reboot the OT. Not only did they build the ST around bringing the old characters/actors back (smart, though obviously the execution fans may be divided on), but they're also showing they want to keep pumping out other movies with those same characters with substitute actors. I just think this will bring the young Leia movie, the young Luke movie (or Luke set at a different time). Rogue One, despite the issues I had, at least created new characters. I don't understand why they don't create something like Rogue One but with legs (something where everyone doesn't have to die and sequels or spinoffs can potentially occur).

I can imagine a situation where they cannot wait to be done with Luke in the new movies so they can have a new actor playing Luke, especially given how Hamill was so vocal about his issues with TLJ.
 
Last edited:
Re: Solo: A Star Wars Story (May 25th, 2018)

Finally watched the trailer for this.

Christ, Lucasfilm is in bad shape. This looks awful. Not only are Ehrenreich and Glover terrible cosplays of Ford and Williams, the movie doesn't even feel like a SW movie.

I gave the theatrical [Gilroy] cut of RO a 7/10. This trailer makes that movie look like a ****ing masterpiece. While I didn't give a damn about Erso's journey nor her team's, at least they inhabited what felt 100% like the world of SW. This trailer fails at the aforementioned miserably. If you took Chewie out along with the Star Destroyer and TIE Fighters the film could easily pass for something that doesn't reside in the SW universe at all.

Terrible cinematography, music, action and Ehrenreich's voice is a slap in the face to anyone who loves the character of Han Solo.

This trailer is just insulting. It's both depressing and comical how low Lucasfilm has sank since the stellar intro to SW they had with TFA.

Is that the dude’s name? Jeez even that sounds like a fail :slap
 
Re: Solo: A Star Wars Story (May 25th, 2018)

Finally watched the trailer for this.

Christ, Lucasfilm is in bad shape. This looks awful. Not only are Ehrenreich and Glover terrible cosplays of Ford and Williams, the movie doesn't even feel like a SW movie.

I gave the theatrical [Gilroy] cut of RO a 7/10. This trailer makes that movie look like a ****ing masterpiece. While I didn't give a damn about Erso's journey nor her team's, at least they inhabited what felt 100% like the world of SW. This trailer fails at the aforementioned miserably. If you took Chewie out along with the Star Destroyer and TIE Fighters the film could easily pass for something that doesn't reside in the SW universe at all.

Terrible cinematography, music, action and Ehrenreich's voice is a slap in the face to anyone who loves the character of Han Solo.

This trailer is just insulting. It's both depressing and comical how low Lucasfilm has sank since the stellar intro to SW they had with TFA.

Is that the dude’s name? Jeez even that sounds like a fail :slap

In German "Ehren" means "to honor" - so the guy's name literally translates as "to honor the Reich." Not a joke.

Adds thematic weight to that scene where he's looking to join the Empire, right?:lol

:exactly:

Hence, why there's a group that wish this project had never been green lit, to me it goes beyond whether this movie is good or not, or whether people can accept this version of Han. I think the trailer looks fine, but wish these were all different characters. To me it signals that Lucasfilm will just milk the heroes, the names we all know, as they're too interested on cashing in.

Ultimately I suspect it means they'll be willing to eventually reboot the OT. Not only did they build the ST around bringing the old characters/actors back (smart, though obviously the execution fans may be divided on), but they're also showing they want to keep pumping out other movies with those new characters with substitute actors. I just think this will is the start of the young Leia movie, the young Luke movie (or Luke set at a different time). Rogue One, despite the issues I had, at least created new characters. I don't understand why they don't create something like Rogue One but with legs (something where everyone doesn't have to die).

I can imagine a situation where they cannot wait to kill off Luke in the movies so they can have a new actor playing Luke, especially given how Hamill was so vocal about his issues with TLJ.

Yeah, it's possible that the better route to go with this might have been a RO-type heist story that centered on new characters aboard the Falcon in a plotline that has a connection to an offscreen Solo, but where they interact with Chewy, Fett and Jabba (and perhaps a Lando brief cameo) and Han is seen with back turned or glimpsed at the very end like Leia, tarkin and Vader in RO.

As I've also said before - they really need to do a "hard prequel" to ESB the same way RO was a hard prequel to ANH - maybe this movie should have been that.
 
Re: Solo: A Star Wars Story (May 25th, 2018)

Is anybody shocked that Clark is using her actual British voice..seems every film I seen her in..she hides it :lol
 
Solo: A Star Wars Story (May 25th, 2018)

The nice thing about ANH was that up until now you could assume that Han's rescue of Luke in the Death Star trench was his first unselfish act (other than rescuing Chewbacca)... but now it will be established that Han is a sucker for unselfish actions after all... so the action taken at the end of ANH will now seem anticlimactic to his character. In fact, it will be expected.

But this is what happens when you expand stories.

I was thinking more like he DOESN’T come to the rescue of someone (Clarke I am looking your way) because he is too busy being a selfish smuggler , and they pay for his selfishness with their lives....which makes the selfless act he does for Luke mean more because he learned his lesson about abandoning friends.....

It would also explain the jaded , self center scoundrel we see.

Another possibility is he trusts his friends and they all screw him over, leaving him marked by Jabba for something he didn’t do alone....

It makes those looks Chewie give him mean even more....


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Re: Solo: A Star Wars Story (May 25th, 2018)

I was thinking more like he DOESN’T come to the rescue of someone (Clarke I am looking your way) because he is too busy being a selfish smuggler , and they pay for his selfishness with their lives....which makes the selfless act he does for Luke mean more because he learned his lesson about abandoning friends.....

It would also explain the jaded , self center scoundrel we see.

Another possibility is he trusts his friends and they all screw him over, leaving him marked by Jabba for something he didn’t do alone....

It makes those looks Chewie give him mean even more....


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Holy cow!!!! This would be GOLD if they take that route!

I gotta feeling they won't :(
 
Re: Solo: A Star Wars Story (May 25th, 2018)

As TaliBane somewhat aludes to, this movie maybe should have been centred around the history of the Millennium Falcon leading up to Han getting it into his possession and not Han himself. Lando could possibly be the main character along with some other new faces.
 
Re: Solo: A Star Wars Story (May 25th, 2018)

Finally watched the trailer for this.

Christ, Lucasfilm is in bad shape. This looks awful. Not only are Ehrenreich and Glover terrible cosplays of Ford and Williams, the movie doesn't even feel like a SW movie.

I gave the theatrical [Gilroy] cut of RO a 7/10. This trailer makes that movie look like a ****ing masterpiece. While I didn't give a damn about Erso's journey nor her team's, at least they inhabited what felt 100% like the world of SW. This trailer fails at the aforementioned miserably. If you took Chewie out along with the Star Destroyer and TIE Fighters the film could easily pass for something that doesn't reside in the SW universe at all.

Terrible cinematography, music, action and Ehrenreich's voice is a slap in the face to anyone who loves the character of Han Solo.

This trailer is just insulting. It's both depressing and comical how low Lucasfilm has sank since the stellar intro to SW they had with TFA.

It has Chewy, Falcon and some actor playing Han. That is all it needs for Star Wars Fanboys to line up for their 18 showings.
 
Re: Solo: A Star Wars Story (May 25th, 2018)

Meh initially I wasn’t a fan but it looks interesting. However I won’t catch it in theaters. These Star Wars movies have failed to capture me to be honest . Kinda sad really.
 
Re: Solo: A Star Wars Story (May 25th, 2018)

I wonder what that makes people who don’t like it, but still pay to see it is then? :monkey3

There's two types:

Those who hate on it but still see it regardless.

And...

Those you hate on it and declare they have no interest in it buy still post pad to the max on a daily basis in the movie thread.

I guess there's a third option too. Those that hate on it publicly but secretly like it but give the impression they hate it to look cool on the Internet.

:dunno
 
Re: Solo: A Star Wars Story (May 25th, 2018)

There's two types:

Those who hate on it but still see it regardless.

And...

Those you hate on it and declare they have no interest in it buy still post pad to the max on a daily basis in the movie thread.


I guess there's a third option too. Those that hate on it publicly but secretly like it but give the impression they hate it to look cool on the Internet.

:dunno

That's the standard MO for the usual suspects here in the movie forum. :lol
 
Re: Solo: A Star Wars Story (May 25th, 2018)

Trailer didn't really show me anything to get excited about (but, to it's credit, didn't come off as a stinking pile of garbage). Alden Ehrenreich isn't giving me much of a "Han" vibe either. I know it's tough to find a young Harrison Ford, but Lucasfilm was able to cast younger versions of characters better before. With Kenobi, Ewan McGregor worked as a decades younger version of Alec Guinness, with Mon Mothma, Genevieve O'Reilly passes for a younger Caroline Blakiston, but this guy doesn't look like what a few years younger version of Han would be expected to look like (and is 5'8" to Ford's 6'1") nor does his voice sound like Ford. Maybe he gets some of the mannerisms or subtle things that Han does in the full movie, maybe the movie ends with him getting plastic surgery and we see a cgi Harrison Ford Han head (still would need to do something with that voice). Personally, I would have preffered them going with Anthony Ingruber (who is 6'0" and played a younger version of Harrison Ford in The Age of Adeline) but that ship has sailed.
 
Re: Solo: A Star Wars Story (May 25th, 2018)

image (1).jpeg

https://ew.com/movies/2018/02/07/solo-a-star-wars-story-pictures-deep-dive/
 
Last edited:
Re: Solo: A Star Wars Story (May 25th, 2018)

I feel like all of these stories have already been hashed out through books, graphic novels, and other media that a movie about it is just pointless. Having said that, Lando looks so boss.
 
Back
Top