Star Wars: Episode IX - THE RISE OF SKYWALKER

Collector Freaks Forum

Help Support Collector Freaks Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
You could probably read it either way. Threepio and R2 clearly aren't battle droids, but automatons may still carry a stigma post Clone Wars.



In the films they were basically background props, so there's that.



As portrayed in the made-for-kids PT (except for the Anakin burning alive limbless part) -- but in-universe they were meant to be mass-produced killing machines, which we may see more of in Mandalorian flashbacks.




Well yeah, that's a product of film and special FX technology as well as the brand's inconsistent writing. Which is likely why you and I disagree, we're both reading into things; I just think my personal canonical blanks as I've filled them in don't mesh with yours. Admittedly, some of yours are more observation-based but we simply have differing opinions on how the greater galactic situation looked from afar.

Yeah, maybe it's observation based (and I realize there can be theories regardless of what's onscreen,) but all I mean is that onscreen no one in the OT seems to be openly and specifically hostile toward droids in the sense of "don't trust these guys, they were Terminators 30 years ago." Even the cantina barkeep to Luke in ANH is more about "keep your horse outside, padre."

What you're talking about is like Ripley and Bishop in Aliens - "don't trust these ****ers." This is an extremely common theme in sci-fi, but not as present in myth/fantasy like SW.

The very fact droids (and lots of them) are background props and pretty much ignored completely as they do their thing - think of the protocol droids in the Hoth base as a good example - seems to confirm there's no specific hostility towards droids in the OT. You'd expect the rebels especially would have a no-droid policy if this was a real thing.

There does seem to be a specific and wide dislike/distrust for Jawas in the OT - maybe they were brutal mass-killers 30 years earlier.:dunno:lol
 
Why can?t both of you be right sheesh.

Cantina bartender feels like Ripley does.

Others tolerate them because they help on the farm.

Roger Roger


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Last edited:
Why can?t both of you be right sheesh.

Dammit jye this is the INTERNET. :rotfl

But yeah, hence "You could probably read it either way." and "we simply have differing opinions" -- it's not like I can prove any of my extrapolations of what's going on in the fictional universe. ;)

Cantina bartender feels like Ripley does.

Others tolerate them because they help on the farm.

Roger Roger


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I like it. :hi5:
 
Dammit jye this is the INTERNET. :rotfl

But yeah, hence "You could probably read it either way." and "we simply have differing opinions" -- it's not like I can prove any of my extrapolations of what's going on in the fictional universe. ;)



I like it. :hi5:

Well, yeah - opinions and theories are not just welcome they're fun to argue.

All I'm saying is there's very little hostility toward droids that's actually seen or heard onscreen in the OT.

And let's face it - these days people can take away two totally opposite things from the same aspect of the REAL universe. I'd argue these days there's more certainty arguing about the rules of a fictional universe than the real world.

And debating/arguing this stuff (rules of a universe) is fun - it's all-in arguing your point so this "why can't both of you be right" is so mom, jye. You ready with the participation trophies?:lol
 
Are ticket sales that low that they gave away a major getaway scene they been teasing from the start of the trailer releases
 
I guess they all forgot leia was flying in deep space .... bobba fett jet packs on strom troopers comes as such a shock to me also ... THEY FLY NOW?!?
 


And just like that...

...any hope I had for this movie just evaporated. F. FFFFFF. WTHF!?!?!?!??!?!??!?!?!!??!?!

At this point the only way to fix things is for Disney to sell Star Wars. Then the new ownership must declare anything that is not in the original 3 movies is no longer canon. They must then hire truly talented teams that actually respect the original material to make new movies going forward.
 
Flying stormtroopers? No matter. Indiana Poe will still successfully escape with the treasure from the ancient mummies tomb.
 
If you have a crappy story the best thing to do is cover it up with lots of action scenes and CGI and hope nobody notices...
 
That was fun. Looking forward to the whole sequence.

Shhhh don?t do that you?re not supposed to say that you liked even just one second of footage you are going to give some folks here an aneurism.

Could you try showing some constraint with any kind words i?m just trying to save you from not being considered one of the cool alpha bros.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Shhhh don?t do that you?re not supposed to say that you liked even just one second of footage you are going to give some folks here an aneurism.

Could you try showing some constraint with any kind words i?m just trying to save you from not being considered one of the cool alpha bros.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

:rotfl

My mistake!
 
Per Jye's post I'd like to recommend you ask why Finn, as a former stormtrooper, is surprised that Stormtroopers can have jet packs. :monkey3

I don't think he's surprised that they CAN have them, but rather that they DO have them. Had he known jetpacks were going to become standard issue, he probably would be gleefully slaughtering defenseless villagers with his stormtrooper buddies rather than fleeing from them.
 
Back
Top