Star Wars: Episode IX - THE RISE OF SKYWALKER
- Thread starter CallMeTheDoctor
- Start date
Help Support Collector Freaks Forum:
I agree... I thought this was a very fitting ending to the Skywalker saga... Grandted.. I did not think I needed it episodes 7 - 9. I was happy with the saga ending at 6. But since they made them this was a great ending for all my fav characters.
Han, Leia, Luke... It was a fitting final to them all.
The saga now feels complete for these characters. Like I said I don't know if I needed it but since we got it they ended it about as perfectly as they could have. For me anyways.
Yes.. I also felt like I was watching a Star Wars movie again. In fact I would say this was the most Star Wars feeling film since the OT. That includes RO and I love that one also.
IDK.. Seems like only the cool members on this board like this film 
I kid
I kid
My full Discussion until it is safe to post without tags
Ok, as with most of my reviews. The easy to read part first , then an analysis.
The Good:
The relationships between the ST cast
Palpatine
Baboo and DO
New force powers.
Backgrounds revealed.
Fast and furious story telling.
Reys answers.
Kylo (drivers) Arc
Lando
Lots of Pew pew and vroom vroom.
The Bad
Horses
Still unexplained Palps resurrection
Finns Secret?
the Goonies Sith Dagger.
Stupor Duper Force Lighting
The Analysis: More like random brain droppings.
Fast and furious pacing is the key here. I did like TLJ, especially Luke's story, but this film is a direct snub of most of that film. And as a result, pretty much invalidates it as a needed watch. While I am sure that makes alot of people happy, it actually makes me a bit frustrated that we pretty much got a wasted SW film.
No SW film will every bring back the spectacle and magic of the viewings most of us had as children, and I never expect them to any more. I am approaching 50 and now all I want is good story, fun characters and an escape to that Galaxy Far Far away.
To me the peak of the SW films will always be ESB, and the end of ROTJ. No film has come close to those moments, this on is no exception.
While its a fun ride , and a nice closure to the ST story line, its not really much of an ending to the "Skywalker Saga". We do get Bens redemption and Reys linage, along with great battles and light saber fights, but the overall reveals feel a bit flat, especially in a "Skywalker Saga" type environment. It all fine and good to have Rey a Palpatine, but I mean did we need that? to me , no not really. If Palps needed an heir, why does he need a family member. The Sith did not need family connections , so why does Palps? In my mind, the whole idea of stealing a body by possession is a cool idea for Sith Masters, and maybe thats a requirement for what Palps was doing. Perhaps those unnatural abilities , are what he was referencing to in ROTS.
I really loved the zombie like Palps, but I really want to know how he is alive.
The out and out ***** slapping this film gave to TLJ....was.....distracting. I mean , we got...Lightsaber insult, X-wing raised,Holdo maneuver too difficult, writing out Rose entirely....and of course, Reys past. It also kinds sad that they have to literally spell out some stuff for today's fans, as they cannot make ANY logical leaps. Do we really need a explanation that Han is NOT a force ghost? Apparently yes to quash the future complaints. SO much of this film seems like a repair letter to the backlash of TLJ. It could have been a smoother run without much of that.
Bens redemption happened the only way it could, the Dark in him had to die. Having HF come back as Han was a welcome surprise, and his rebirth from Rey was the link he needed to see what he was missing. And his following Sacrifice makes his redemption complete and a selfless act. I liked the light saber projecting to him, and the resulting change in his fighting style. Driver really sells the transformation, something that should have begun in TLJ, so it could have been explored more.
This film is REALLY good looking as well. If you cannot give JJ credit for anything else, at least have the ability to grant that he can really direct a film to capture the shots ni the best way possible. Its a gorgeous film , especially in IMAX.
Seeing Luke train Leia was a great scene, short as it was....and again, totally out of order. Highlighting why you map out a plan for the biggest sequels of all time. BIG fail in Disney planning there.
Mark Hamill looked really unhealthy.
The 3po plot line was great, and glad to see he didn't go all AOTC battle droid (god was that the worst scene in any SW film ever). Poe little arc was really cool and the new characters Zorii and Jannah were tastefully used. Can we say spinoff series for Lando helping Jannah find the lost Stormtrooper boys and girls? I am sure thats coming.
Finns Secret< He IS force sensitive. BUT talk about dropping a plot line?
I must admit, the passing of Leia was heartbreaking for me. The reality of her actual death is still shocking to me, as is Peter, and Kenny and David. Time is marching on, and our childhood heroes are leaving us one by one. Really touching they gave her top billing in the credits.
I stayed away from any leaks, and was rewarded , as to me most of the plot was a nice surprise and a really fun ride. I kinda suspected Rey would be related to someone, as as Palps made a return , he was a possibility. To my family , who are SW fans by extension of my fandom, they were REALLY shocked by this. They all loved the movie as well. Most of my sons friends who saw it , liked it as well.
As a contrast, the nit picking "true" fans will tear it apart as they always do. There is alot in here for them to hate on, new force abilities, new characters, new heroes. Lately, I understand the people who have the true level of venom for the ST. They are incapable of seeing anything new that was not in the OT. If it did not exist in the 6 hours of the original story, then its impossible and stupid to them. Well, my Galaxy far Far away is much bigger than that, and has much more to show us, and I am glad. Let the purists keep watching the OT over and over, and I will keep deriving joy from the expanding Universe as a whole. I will take more movies and more films any day.(Madalorian!) They will not all be great, and none will every reach the level of OT, but I remember all to well being a kid and wanting more SW in my life and getting nothing for over a decade. Of course your mileage may (and will ) vary.
These are first impressions as there is ALOT to sort through here. Supplemental materials will fill in the holes, and will some just plain old common sense (yes Palpatine could have had a wife and kids, we do not need a real explanation for that, maybe that story explains his turn to the dark side...but we really do not need it.)
Overall I am going to try to see it again, but being an adult right now is taking up loads of my free time. I hope to squeeze in a viewing the week of January 1st. But this one was up there in the Star Wars Adventure series of films
Obligatory list in order.
ESB
ANH
ROTJ
RO
TFA
TROS
SOLO
ROTS/TLJ (tough comparison for me)
TPM
ATOC
The Good:
The relationships between the ST cast
Palpatine
Baboo and DO
New force powers.
Backgrounds revealed.
Fast and furious story telling.
Reys answers.
Kylo (drivers) Arc
Lando
Lots of Pew pew and vroom vroom.
The Bad
Horses
Still unexplained Palps resurrection
Finns Secret?
the Goonies Sith Dagger.
Stupor Duper Force Lighting
The Analysis: More like random brain droppings.
Fast and furious pacing is the key here. I did like TLJ, especially Luke's story, but this film is a direct snub of most of that film. And as a result, pretty much invalidates it as a needed watch. While I am sure that makes alot of people happy, it actually makes me a bit frustrated that we pretty much got a wasted SW film.
No SW film will every bring back the spectacle and magic of the viewings most of us had as children, and I never expect them to any more. I am approaching 50 and now all I want is good story, fun characters and an escape to that Galaxy Far Far away.
To me the peak of the SW films will always be ESB, and the end of ROTJ. No film has come close to those moments, this on is no exception.
While its a fun ride , and a nice closure to the ST story line, its not really much of an ending to the "Skywalker Saga". We do get Bens redemption and Reys linage, along with great battles and light saber fights, but the overall reveals feel a bit flat, especially in a "Skywalker Saga" type environment. It all fine and good to have Rey a Palpatine, but I mean did we need that? to me , no not really. If Palps needed an heir, why does he need a family member. The Sith did not need family connections , so why does Palps? In my mind, the whole idea of stealing a body by possession is a cool idea for Sith Masters, and maybe thats a requirement for what Palps was doing. Perhaps those unnatural abilities , are what he was referencing to in ROTS.
I really loved the zombie like Palps, but I really want to know how he is alive.
The out and out ***** slapping this film gave to TLJ....was.....distracting. I mean , we got...Lightsaber insult, X-wing raised,Holdo maneuver too difficult, writing out Rose entirely....and of course, Reys past. It also kinds sad that they have to literally spell out some stuff for today's fans, as they cannot make ANY logical leaps. Do we really need a explanation that Han is NOT a force ghost? Apparently yes to quash the future complaints. SO much of this film seems like a repair letter to the backlash of TLJ. It could have been a smoother run without much of that.
Bens redemption happened the only way it could, the Dark in him had to die. Having HF come back as Han was a welcome surprise, and his rebirth from Rey was the link he needed to see what he was missing. And his following Sacrifice makes his redemption complete and a selfless act. I liked the light saber projecting to him, and the resulting change in his fighting style. Driver really sells the transformation, something that should have begun in TLJ, so it could have been explored more.
This film is REALLY good looking as well. If you cannot give JJ credit for anything else, at least have the ability to grant that he can really direct a film to capture the shots ni the best way possible. Its a gorgeous film , especially in IMAX.
Seeing Luke train Leia was a great scene, short as it was....and again, totally out of order. Highlighting why you map out a plan for the biggest sequels of all time. BIG fail in Disney planning there.
Mark Hamill looked really unhealthy.
The 3po plot line was great, and glad to see he didn't go all AOTC battle droid (god was that the worst scene in any SW film ever). Poe little arc was really cool and the new characters Zorii and Jannah were tastefully used. Can we say spinoff series for Lando helping Jannah find the lost Stormtrooper boys and girls? I am sure thats coming.
Finns Secret< He IS force sensitive. BUT talk about dropping a plot line?
I must admit, the passing of Leia was heartbreaking for me. The reality of her actual death is still shocking to me, as is Peter, and Kenny and David. Time is marching on, and our childhood heroes are leaving us one by one. Really touching they gave her top billing in the credits.
I stayed away from any leaks, and was rewarded , as to me most of the plot was a nice surprise and a really fun ride. I kinda suspected Rey would be related to someone, as as Palps made a return , he was a possibility. To my family , who are SW fans by extension of my fandom, they were REALLY shocked by this. They all loved the movie as well. Most of my sons friends who saw it , liked it as well.
As a contrast, the nit picking "true" fans will tear it apart as they always do. There is alot in here for them to hate on, new force abilities, new characters, new heroes. Lately, I understand the people who have the true level of venom for the ST. They are incapable of seeing anything new that was not in the OT. If it did not exist in the 6 hours of the original story, then its impossible and stupid to them. Well, my Galaxy far Far away is much bigger than that, and has much more to show us, and I am glad. Let the purists keep watching the OT over and over, and I will keep deriving joy from the expanding Universe as a whole. I will take more movies and more films any day.(Madalorian!) They will not all be great, and none will every reach the level of OT, but I remember all to well being a kid and wanting more SW in my life and getting nothing for over a decade. Of course your mileage may (and will ) vary.
These are first impressions as there is ALOT to sort through here. Supplemental materials will fill in the holes, and will some just plain old common sense (yes Palpatine could have had a wife and kids, we do not need a real explanation for that, maybe that story explains his turn to the dark side...but we really do not need it.)
Overall I am going to try to see it again, but being an adult right now is taking up loads of my free time. I hope to squeeze in a viewing the week of January 1st. But this one was up there in the Star Wars Adventure series of films
Obligatory list in order.
ESB
ANH
ROTJ
RO
TFA
TROS
SOLO
ROTS/TLJ (tough comparison for me)
TPM
ATOC
Sachiel
Super Freak
- Joined
- Dec 19, 2005
- Messages
- 11,661
- Reaction score
- 828
The ST makes sense if the blue energy in ROTJ was Palpatine force-teleporting and ending up in an alternate universe.
Of course it does. They're all dead!
SilverStar17
Super Freak
Apparently, the reactor core on the DSII was one giant Tesseract.
Vader did way worse than kill him; he teleported and banished him to the ST.
Hi, didn't read all pages. It must have been discussed already. I enjoyed TROS very much. But this issue bothers me:
If Rey defeats Palpatine who is stronger than ever, then how come Anakin be the chosen one. It looks like Rey is the chosen one at first instance.
I can come to an explanation but it stucks at some point.
Palpatine has the power of all the Sith before. And Rey can not defeat him alone, she defeated him with the support of all the Jedi before her. So, when looking from this point Rey does not become chosen one and the situation turns into all the sith vs all the jedi confrontation. This view resolves the issue Rey being the chosen one by turning her into a vehicle. Then comes the part where I stuck. All the Sith vs all the Jedi is a bigger confrontation than Palpatine vs Vader in ROTJ. So, a chosen one must also play a role in this confrontation too. I can not resolve this.
If JJ have shown Force ghost of Anakin passing his Force to Rey, this would have been cleared but in this situation, I can not resolve. How do you see this aspect?
So,
1-Is Rey chosen one? No, she didn't beat him alone, she used all previous Jedi's support.
2-If Anakin's the chosen one, then this confrontation is not important as ROTJ, or
3-Anakin played a critical part in this final battle but not shown to us.
If this did not hamper Anakin, I would have been totally satisfied.
If Rey defeats Palpatine who is stronger than ever, then how come Anakin be the chosen one. It looks like Rey is the chosen one at first instance.
I can come to an explanation but it stucks at some point.
Palpatine has the power of all the Sith before. And Rey can not defeat him alone, she defeated him with the support of all the Jedi before her. So, when looking from this point Rey does not become chosen one and the situation turns into all the sith vs all the jedi confrontation. This view resolves the issue Rey being the chosen one by turning her into a vehicle. Then comes the part where I stuck. All the Sith vs all the Jedi is a bigger confrontation than Palpatine vs Vader in ROTJ. So, a chosen one must also play a role in this confrontation too. I can not resolve this.
If JJ have shown Force ghost of Anakin passing his Force to Rey, this would have been cleared but in this situation, I can not resolve. How do you see this aspect?
So,
1-Is Rey chosen one? No, she didn't beat him alone, she used all previous Jedi's support.
2-If Anakin's the chosen one, then this confrontation is not important as ROTJ, or
3-Anakin played a critical part in this final battle but not shown to us.
If this did not hamper Anakin, I would have been totally satisfied.
Oh no it isn't.
With it's laughable dialogue and plot holes TROS is a prime candidate for Mystery Science Theater 3000.
see here come the nit picks.....SW fans cannot seem to put two and two together unless its spelled out for them.
Maybe the fixed it?????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
That Mandalorian fellow basically puts his ENTIRE ship back together after it was completely ripped apart.......
No one even blinked at that
And this is what you decide to run with....try again
- Joined
- Mar 13, 2010
- Messages
- 27,932
- Reaction score
- 31,817
see here come the nit picks.....SW fans cannot seem to put two and two together unless its spelled out for them.
Maybe the fixed it?????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
That Mandalorian fellow basically puts his ENTIRE ship back together after it was completely ripped apart.......
No one even blinked at that
And this is what you decide to run with....try again
It came out of the water intact with all guns attached by the S-foils.
According to leaks JJ reached out to him for story advice for the first cut of TROS, which Disney promptly threw in the trash because the villain wasn't a huge Sith Lord like Palpatine. It's rumored that's who Matt Smith was playing before they cut him from the project. Originally Palpatine wasn't going to have a physical presence in the movie at all, but would still be referenced.
There's allegedly six different cuts of this movie. Six.
This is something I'd like to see.
The Clown Prince of Crime
Super Freak
Palpatine surviving at the end of ROTJ is ridiculous only because it was never intended for him to survive, so there is no logical or believable answer for it. As soon as he goes down there's a huge explosion, so there was no time for him to escape or to be rescued by someone. Assuming someone found his body later(which is ridiculous because there should be nothing left ) and since Disney is all about fan fiction, it is possible that the empire or whatever is after Baby Yoda to use him to help a dead or barely alive Palpatine.
However, this film kind of made Snoke more interesting tho, because it creates more questions than it answers, which is ironic since the purpose of this film was to retcon the last film and try to make sense of things. So at what point was Snoke created? It's implied that the first order had no idea that Palpatine was alive or that he had all those fleets underground with thousands of people in them for 40 years. Was Snoke autonomous or was he just an empty vessel for Palpatine to use as an avatar style body? If so, did he pick the gold robes and sandals? If not, and Snoke was independent, did he know he was a clone? Did he know Palpatine or that he was being used? If so, was he responsible for Palpatine's fleets? How does his now legendary underwhelming death factor into all of this, and what role did Palpatine play in it, if at all? So many dumb question.
However, this film kind of made Snoke more interesting tho, because it creates more questions than it answers, which is ironic since the purpose of this film was to retcon the last film and try to make sense of things. So at what point was Snoke created? It's implied that the first order had no idea that Palpatine was alive or that he had all those fleets underground with thousands of people in them for 40 years.
Was Snoke autonomous or was he just an empty vessel for Palpatine to use as an avatar style body? If so, did he pick the gold robes and sandals? If not, and Snoke was independent, did he know he was a clone? Did he know Palpatine or that he was being used? If so, was he responsible for Palpatine's fleets? How does his now legendary underwhelming death factor into all of this, and what role did Palpatine play in it, if at all? So many dumb question.
Yep. Pacing for me makes this one eminently more watchable than the other two in the ST. They all have their "controversial" moments -- TLJ moreso -- but at least this one pushes you so quickly to the next beat (or issue) that you get as distracted as Kylo by his mother.
I wonder if she spoke to him or just force-tapped him on the shoulder?
I have to say I liked him more as Ben Solo... made me wish they started the ST with Ben Solo and then followed his fall at the end of the first movie, becoming Kylo at the top of the 2nd movie... you know, the way they should have done the PT.
It's not because JJ retconned TLJ, it's because there's actually nothing happened in TLJ. Apart from Rey's training and Canto scenes which resulted in nothing, the movie was about resistance escaping from one enormous starship. So, since there wasn't a story, regardless of good or bad, ST can be watched without TLJ.
Getter Dragon
Checklist Freak
I did like a thousand pages ago... lol.
No, thank you! It's refreshing to see someone who wants to engage in discourse instead of immediately jumping to accusations like you are just a racist/sexist/mysogynist/moron/hater/salty whenever anyone criticizes these movies. When I say these movies are trash I am not insulting anyone other than the creators of these movies, but a lot of people on this board take it personally as if they own a stake in Star Wars. You can't have constructive discussions with fanboys and apologists who are easily distracted by lightsabers and spaceships, so I don't bother.
Contrary to popular belief (and I do realize most of my posts come off like this), but I don't hate these movies per se, rather, I experience pure disappointment at what should have been; especially after watching TROS. I never said these movies were not well made, my objections with the ST (and PT for that matter) have to do with lore-breaking plot points and the overarching 40-year-old narrative and character arcs and how they have been discarded/wasted/ruined along the way (which makes sense given my professional background in a creative industry) and not little details or minor plot-holes.
I have two primary problems with TROS:
1. This movie seems like a rushed jumbled mess because it's actually two movies in one. It's JJ's Episode 8 & 9 mushed together because of Ruin's folly. TLJ was the lore-breaking end of a series and closed most of the narrative threads leaving no where for the story to go. Ruin is an incompetent writer even though his direction is beautiful. JJ had to setup an entire previous movie in TROS in order to continue a story and it shows. For example, all the stuff about getting a transmission from Palpatine and Kylo eventually finding him should have been the plot of 8. The end of 8 should have been Palpatine telling Kylo to find Rey. Skipping over massive plot points like that is dissatisfying. This trilogy would have been so much better had JJ made all 3 movies.
2. TROS wiped away everything Lucas wrote wholesale. The Skywalkers don't matter. Their lineage lasted a blink of an eye and are now all dead and had absolutely no impact on the overall narrative. It took a Palpatine to destroy a Palpatine. The Skywalkers are just a footnote in their own saga. Vader/Luke/Leia/Ben were not the chosen ones or brought balance to the Force - that was all Rey Palpatine who was born completely independently of the Skywalker brood. I think Obi-Wan's voice during the final battle even tells Rey to "rise and bring balance to the force". Talk about pissing all over Lucas' creation. This entire saga turned out to be the "Rise of Rey" and is the natural outcome of Kathleen Kennedy's misandrist agenda and not 40+ years of science-fantasy storytelling.
This entire debacle lies at the feet of Kathleen Kennedy. She had one job - grow the brand to include young girls and women, visible minorities, and the Chinese market because the more people that love Star Wars, the more money Disney stockholders will make on merchandise sales. But through her gross incompetence she has actually shrunk the original consumer base, shooed away a large number of OG fans, failed to attract a new, young generation of fans (Marvel has taken over the hearts and imaginations of younglings today) and women, young girls and minorities still don't care about Star Wars. The brand is DOA in China and has only appealed to virtue-signaling twitter mobs who want to be perceived as SJWs without actually doing anything concrete to help marginalized populations that need it. I don't see these loud-mouthed a***oles volunteering at women's shelters or coaching at-risk youth, but I do see them vomiting insults and stupidity all over social media. These are also people who have no interest in buying expensive Star Wars dolls like us or any other merchandise - no more sweet sweet SW money for you Disney; that honeypot has dried up. Lagging merchandise earnings and flopping movies prove this point.
And of course, Lucas has no love for these movies, so I will join the creator of Star Wars on that side of the fence.
Sorry for writing all this crap no one wants to read and I also wish you a happy and safe holiday!
The Clown Prince of Crime
Super Freak
The first trilogy made of two films.
Holiday Cheers from you know who...
Have a Xmas peanut and see yourself some Star Wars.
Have a Xmas peanut and see yourself some Star Wars.
Getter Dragon
Checklist Freak
The first trilogy made of two films.
Exactly! You summed up half my post in six words... lol!
see here come the nit picks.....SW fans cannot seem to put two and two together unless its spelled out for them.
Maybe the fixed it?????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????
That Mandalorian fellow basically puts his ENTIRE ship back together after it was completely ripped apart.......
No one even blinked at that
And this is what you decide to run with....try again
You don't realize The Mandalorian is the Star Wars version of Alita Battle Angel? Remember the people bashing Captain Marvel and at the same time bigging up and trying to get people to watch Alita instead. Its the same thing here. Those people bash Rise of Skywalker and over look any short comings in the Mandalorian while hyping it endlessly.
Ropen
Super Freak
What?s baffling also is the fact that Two versions of the same Obi Wan come up, Ewan and Sir Alec during the same scene, like they had to!!
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Similar threads
