A LONG TIME AGO IN A GALAXY FAR FAR AWAY
N E R D W A R S
Like the PT it kind of started with a trade dispute! A certain IP holder was annoyed that a lot of 1/6 scale boot leg figures were being sold of their IP and they weren't getting the licence fee cheques for them. They looked to Sideshow to try and screw down on this activity as they were one of their legitimate licence holders in the 1/6 field in the US. This website used to be an affiliate of Sideshow and I believe used to receive sponsorship from them in the form of advertisement fees (the banner at the top of the page used to link to SideshowCollectors.com) ? once upon a time Sideshow reps even came to the boards to discuss figures but they were scared away by angry collectors critiquing their work. Sideshow flexed their muscles and told all affiliates (including this board) that if they continued to discuss these bootleg figures or advertised them in anyway then they would lose 'affiliate' status and the perks that went with that. There was a lot of confusion around what a 'bootleg' meant as this board used to a have a very healthy customs section (it was honestly awesome) and Sideshow seemed confused as well by what the certain IP holder wanted so they erred on the side of caution to ban all bootlegs and custom projects. Dave (the dude in charge of this board) did his very best to balance what Sideshow had 'requested' but also manage the removal of the customs scene (there were a lot of ongoing projects with a lot of money invested in them which couldn't just disappear over night otherwise people would be left high and dry) ? long story short Sideshow got spooked and pulled the 'affliate' status and this board suffered as a result (the customs scene was already gone by this point anyway so it was a loss a loss all round).
At the same time a massive nerd war was waging in the TLJ thread between those who legit loved TLJ (the misguided love anything Star Wars progressive feminist types) versus those who really hated it (the whiny basement dwelling self-entitled neck-bearded incel man-babies... of which I was one, frothing at the mouth as I posted here). The nerd war was like no other before it the mods swung their mighty ban hammers mercilessly (mostly... almost entirely.... ok 100%) banning only the most whiny of the TLJ haters in a bid to make the TLJ board a safe space for TLJ lovers.
A rival we hate TLJ page was started and for a time all was well again. No-one knows who fired the first shot but somehow the streams crossed. Before you knew it, we had TLJ lovers in the 'we h8 TLJ' thread spouting their fluffy love for it and TLJ h8rs spitting their vile bile hatred all over the 'we wuv TLJ' thread. The ban hammers were lifted and swung again ? landing coincidentally only on the heads of the TLJ h8rs (bad luck I guess). The threads were locked down and again for a time there was peace. Then all the h8rs started to vent their anger in the legit toy threads where you were only meant to discuss upcoming figures. This tiny minority of haters kept getting larger despite the ban hammer culling their numbers.... it was a dark time indeed.
As a result of the customs schism a new custom boards were springing up all over the place. It was at this time that many of the h8rs angry at TLJ and the prejudice of the ban hammer left for this new pasture free to ridicule TLJ to their hearts content. I put a foot in the door for a time but I missed the passion of wuvvy TLJ lovers and their (sometimes) convoluted way of re-contextualising the OT to fit the ST... sad to hear the other place tore itself a part.
In the end a new TLJ thread was opened where the luvvers could talk mostly undisturbed. The odd TLJ hating weed would spout up but the TLJ triple threat of AJP (with his vast Star Wars knowledge and verbose but sound arguments), Khev (also with almost unparalleled Star Wars geek knowledge - though Khev flip-flopped on his luv for TLJ, often playing devils advocate to keep the discussion alive) and Jye (with his funny meme army) would annihilate them into submission ... mostly. And again for a time there was peace.
Then TROS came and the well drawn lines of wuv and h8 were thrown out of the window. AJP, once the staunchest defender of TLJ, did a heel turn casting aside his love for the ST but rather than hate he only had apathy towards it. Jaws returned from the unknown regions to fill the void left behind by AJP's absence, declaring his retrospective love for all things ST. Khev and Jye were overjoyed and too declared their love for all things ST. Alas there was no one left for them to battle. Like Grandmaster AJP, TROS had turned the h8rs and many of the previous wuvvers to apathy, hardly anyone legit cared about the ST anymore.
The force dyad of Khev and Jye led by new supreme leader Jaws every so often try to kick the PT hornets nest to have someone to debate with and so keep this thread and the ST alive, but the debates are tired. Everyone knows that the PT is superior in world building with more interesting characters and designs (and a better over-arching plot narrative) whilst the ST had Mark Hamill, Carrie and Ford, better acting and was a homage to the OT (read looked like and basically ripped it off).
Like BY, Mando has force heeled some and returned them to their former Star Wars love (remember before the ST we all used to like Star Wars, if not all parts of it, enough to be satisfied by it) but it seems it may not be enough to save all. The legacy of KK and the ST is not the force is female but the force is apathy.