jaztermareal is saying that most of the 1's are genuine because the show is bad and people hate it, but most, or a least a lot, of the 10s are fake because a minority have admitted to voting 10 to counter the 1's.
My argument is that just because a small minority on one side has admitted something and the other hasn't, doesn't mean that's how things are actually going down.
..as I understand it at least.
What I said was not that most 1's are genuine vs most 10's not, I said that 1's are more likely to be genuine than 10's based simply on A: how a project fits into a universe (subjective) vs how well made it is (objective) and B: the psychology of negative emotions eliciting action more often than positive ones. People who are angry are more likely to dismiss something entirely vs people who are happy to embrace something fully. When a show is bad it will anger folk more and anger is a strong motivator, so 1's will be genuine more often than 10's even if not objective.
Those who rate it 10 to stick it to the trolls are also motivated by negativity too, except theirs is not to do with the show/creators but with the fanbase, so their opnion is not about the quality of the product but the quality of the consumer, making it less valid than the haters who's opinion is on the quality of the product and its creators.
This means that (as an example) 40% of 1's (not most, but a sizable minority) could be coming from a genuine opinion while only 20% of the 10's come from genuine opinion of the show. In both cases the majority of 1's and 10's are not genuine but the 1's are more likely to be genuine than the 10's.
And nowhere did I ever claim that 1 side admitting to false score while the other doesn't means only 1 side is lying/not genuine, not sure where that came from. We know both engage in artificial inflating/deflating of score, it is simply a case of if the ratio's of dishonest rating match.
EDIT again: also, I was arguing Devils advocate style to explain why some are willing to count 1's but ignore 10's, my actual opinion as posted earlier: "Which is why I suggested ignoring all 1/5 (1, 1.5 and 2/10) and all 5/5 (9, 9.5 and 10/10) ratings. What is in between is more accurate."
. 
