Star Wars: The Last Jedi (Dec 15th, 2017)

Collector Freaks Forum

Help Support Collector Freaks Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Status
Not open for further replies.
Wasn’t Holdo using their biggest ship? Last I checked that wasn’t a fighter.

I could post a bunch of screenshots of Rebel Transports, Medical Frigates and other big Rebel ships heading toward Star Destroyers in the OT, but you get the idea.:lol

The issue with that line of questioning is that the Rebels in the OT had quite a number of similarly-sized ships to the one Holdo uses, so even if you don't accept fighters going in hyperspace destroying Star Destroyers (which I do - Holdo's ramming produced damage far, far greater than a big ship ramming another big ship at speed, suggesting hyperspace itself enhances damage enormously, possibly regardless of ship size) there are many examples where they could have used it.

If the Rebellion throughout the OT was down to only one or two big ships like in TLJ, I could maybe accept the argument - but they aren't at all (the Resistance is down to a space-bicycle and space-jet-ski by the end of TLJ, so maybe we'll see who's right with the ramming in Ep IX.:rotfl)

It all comes back to this lame "didn't think of that before..." idea - which given the high-stakes and desperation of the OT, is absolutely laughable and willful evasion.
 
Oto until this post I had no idea that they were.

I need to give you a :hi5: for opening my eyes to what everyone kept secret from me for my entire life.

I hope I don’t become a bother but may I please come to you for all my further lessons in life especially since you are so confident with your findings...pleaseeeeee Oto. :pray:

I can’t wait to share with Khev and rushmore your findings!

Khev Khev, rush rush did you guys hear what oto discovered! :panic:



I'm waiting for the scientific evidence to be presented, I'm very hesitant to just take somebody's word on this.
 
I could post a bunch of screenshots of Rebel Transports, Medical Frigates and other big Rebel ships heading toward Star Destroyers in the OT, but you get the idea.:lol

The issue with that line of questioning is that the Rebels in the OT had quite a number of similarly-sized ships to the one Holdo uses, so even if you don't accept fighters going in hyperspace destroying Star Destroyers (which I do - Holdo's ramming produced damage far, far greater than a big ship ramming another big ship at speed, suggesting hyperspace itself enhances damage enormously, possibly regardless of ship size) there are many examples where they could have used it.

If the Rebellion throughout the OT was down to only one or two big ships like in TLJ, I could maybe accept the argument - but they aren't at all (the Resistance is down to a space-bicycle and space-jet-ski by the end of TLJ, so maybe we'll see who's right with the ramming in Ep IX.:rotfl)

It all comes back to this lame "didn't think of that before..." idea - which given the high-stakes and desperation of the OT, is absolutely laughable and willful evasion.

But isn’t that part logical? I can throw a bullet at someone etc. but shooting a needle at some vs a cannonball makes quite a difference in terms of the damage. Also we live in a world where new things are being weaponized all the time—trucks driving over a street full of people (not like trucks are a new device)—so it doesn’t seem so far fetched. I think I’m with Jaws on this one, just in that if the movie were amazing to everyone this would be a much more minor issue. As is, there are indeed so many issues that it opens up so much (especially anything new) to being picked apart.
 
But isn’t that part logical? I can throw a bullet at someone etc. but shooting a needle at some vs a cannonball makes quite a difference in terms of the damage. Also we live in a world where new things are being weaponized all the time—trucks driving over a street full of people (not like trucks are a new device)—so it doesn’t seem so far fetched. I think I’m with Jaws on this one, just in that if the movie were amazing to everyone this would be a much more minor issue. As is, there are indeed so many issues that it opens up so much (especially anything new) to being picked apart.

All I mean is that what it produced was this surreal, abstracted visual almost like the cosmic blur of Kubrick's 2001, which suggested to me that hyperspace itself (I guess bending the fabric of space-time or whatever) did most of the damage, not necessarily the size of the ship that created the hyperspace "vortex/hole/whatever."

Otherwise it would be a flash of hyperspace like normal, a hole (dependent on size of attacking ship) appearing through the hull of the star destroyer, and then a big ol' regular explosion. Instead we got the Jimi Hendrix and Jim Morrison of collision outcomes.:lol

But yeah - to be fair, TLJ was a blur of Flying Nuns, saggy teats (clarification: green milk variety,) dyed beards, bullet-time Luke and the battle of Not-Hoth.

Weaponizing hyperspace was probably the least of my problems with it - but because it makes the rebels in the OT come across as dolts ("OMG... why didn't we think of that? It's so OBVIOUS!"), it still kinda bugs me.:dunno
 
But can ghosts interact with ghosts? (Other than hang out and smile?)

Yoda interacting with the real world does seem problematic and unnecessary. Just let Luke burn it.

All those Jedis who died in the PT... coming back to do battle again as ghosts.:horror:lol
 
Han stepping over Jabba tail is 100 x worse than anything in TLJ.

I forgot how bad that looked damn Lucas you’re a ****ing nut case.
 
Han stepping over Jabba tail is 100 x worse than anything in TLJ.

I forgot how bad that looked damn Lucas you’re a ****ing nut case.
Quite a few of the ‘97 gold box changes were nutty, with that and the Greedo shootout being the most jarring.

It got even worse with the DVD collection. The heck was he thinking with some of these changes? The icing on the cake was the addition of that horrendous “Noooooo” that Vader yelps out right before tossing the Emperor into the frying pan, which was the worst change in the blu ray collection, thankfully, but still.
 
Just got done watching Lady Bird but couldn't help but seek a little TLJ fix before heading to the car and peaked into a 2D showing *right* as Luke's saber exploded followed immediately by Holdo going to lightspeed. And that scene is now 3 for 3 with always having one single person in the audience letting out a "whoaaaa!" among the crowd during the silence as if to verbalize what everyone was thinking. I can't remember the last modern film to elicit such a reaction. Takes me all the way back to watching the T-1000 rise from the tile floor for the first time. Such an epic freaking moment.

I stayed to watch the Finn/Phasma duel and then headed out before getting sucked in to the Battle of Crait. I really like how Rose's shot ricochets harmlessly off Phasma's armor.
 
I have another 'why' for you...considering their seemingly limitless resources - how come every trooper in the Quack Legion isn't outfitted with blaster-bolt deflecting armor?...or at least more than one of them :lol
 
Last edited:
I have another 'why' for you...considering their seemingly limitless resources - how come every trooper in the Quack Legion isn't outfitted with blaster-bolt deflecting armor?

The bean counters figured a soldier's life wasn't worth the three hundred grand.

FAAayoR.gif
 
I have another 'why' for you...considering their seemingly limitless resources - how come every trooper in the Quack Legion isn't outfitted with blaster-bolt deflecting armor?...or at least more than one of them :lol

Probably so that Phasma has an easier time blowing away deserters. ;)

And lol Clown. :lol
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top