The Dark Knight Rises *SPOILERS*

[Shai]

This movie isn't the best movie of this trilogy (that goes to TDK) so for me it can't be the best film of the year. This movie is closer to BB level than TDK at least for me and I especially think that after seeing all three of then in the same day. TDKR has several awesome sequences but it has some bad ones as well. I thought hardy as Bane and Hathaway as Catwoman did a better job than anyone else. I will buy it on Blu and will take my dad to see it, but if I had to score this on a 10 scale it would get 7.5/10.

yeah great unbiased review, Josh...I agree with everything you said except i'd give it 6.5/10.

 

[wofford29]

Unbiased,

 

[Shai]

How is it a personal attack when you're trolling your opinion?

If you can dish it out, you better be able to take it too.

And as a mod you should lead by exemple.How old are you seriously? 22?

 

[Shai]

Unbiased,

 

[Shai]

^notice the green and purple colors....

 

[wofford29]

Shai, I hope like hell they finally make a good Hulk film next just so I can witness your posts.

 

[jye4ever]

LOL at last few pages.

 

[intothevoid]

And as a mod you should lead by exemple.How old are you seriously? 22?

And my example is to express my opinion as just that, my opinion.

I don't have any problems with people not liking the film, but saying it over and over in one liners without adding anything whatsoever in terms of critique or discussion is the very definition of trolling.

 

[Shai]

Shai, I hope like hell they finally make a good Hulk film next just so I can witness your posts.

You see, I can I agree with that...Both Hulk movie were crappy.

 

[macapaolo]

I watched it last night. I was so disappointed. I found myself trying hard to like the movie. I hate to say this but this is the first Nolan movie I didn't like.

 

[The Josh]

yeah great unbiased review, Josh...I agree with everything you said except i'd give it 6.5/10.

Thank ya sir

Unbiased,

What part of what I said was biased? I liked the movie, liked the trilogy, etc. I'm no hater of these films but I don't think they walk on water either so if that makes me a hater it's ok.

 

[Shai]

And my example is to express my opinion as just that, my opinion.

I don't have any problems with people not liking the film, but saying it over and over in one liners without adding anything whatsoever in terms of critique or discussion is the very definition of trolling.

My first language is french, not my fault I dont make more than a couple sentences of my opinion, it would barely be readable for most of you...This is what happens when Dave choose a N00b as a mod, you dont even know the posters here except if they post in a Batman thread.I could also make you a dissertation in french about why I didnt like the movie though but not sure you could answer in my language with more than a one -liner...

 

[Boba Ben]

What part of what I said was biased? I liked the movie, liked the trilogy, etc. I'm no hater of these films but I don't think they walk on water either so if that makes me a hater it's ok.

You are a pretty big Iron Man fan from what I've read here.

I actually liked this movie a lot. I am not a crazy fan of the Nolan films in certain respects, and '89 Batman is my favorite Batman movie, but I really enjoyed. I'll get it on blu-ray when it comes out.

 

[intothevoid]

My first language is french, not my fault I dont make more than a couple sentences of my opinion, it would barely be readable for most of you...This is what happens when Dave choose a N00b as a mod, you dont even know the posters here...I could also make you a dissertation in french about why I didnt like the movie though but not sure you could answer in my language with more than a one -liner...

SO now i'm a noob

Feel free to post your critique in French - google translate is a wonderful thing.

 

[wofford29]

What part of what I said was biased? I liked the movie, liked the trilogy, etc. I'm no hater of these films but I don't think they walk on water either so if that makes me a hater it's ok.

It's not your words that make your review biased it's the idea of someone who is in love with Marvel reviewing it lower than something DC is to be expected. There's nothing wrong with that. It goes the same way in reverse for DC fans. There's not going to be an unbiased review on these boards because we're all fans of this stuff and even if we like it all, we still pick sides.

 

[Fernandofan08]

My first language is french, not my fault I dont make more than a couple sentences of my opinion, it would barely be readable for most of you...This is what happens when Dave choose a N00b as a mod, you dont even know the posters here except if they post in a Batman thread.I could also make you a dissertation in french about why I didnt like the movie though but not sure you could answer in my language with more than a one -liner...

Ah, instant validation for criticising everything then being a frenchie. Sucks to be you

 

[Jokes & Bats]

SO now i'm a noob

Feel free to post your critique in French - google translate is a wonderful thing.

For a mod, Void, you really shouldn't be getting into back and forths between other members of the boards. Surely a mod's role is to set an example as well as maintain a purposeful and pleasant community.

 

[The Josh]

You are a pretty big Iron Man fan from what I've read here.

I actually liked this movie a lot. I am not a crazy fan of the Nolan films in certain respects, and '89 Batman is my favorite Batman movie, but I really enjoyed. I'll get it on blu-ray when it comes out.

Yeah, I prefer the iron man movies more but I would have no problem if this or any of the other batman films were better. If I was a hater I'd never have anything good to say about the Nolan batman films for which I do like.

 

[Shai]

For a mod, Void, you really shouldn't be getting into back and forths between other members of the boards. Surely a mod's role is to set an example as well as maintain a purposeful and pleasant community.

 

[The Josh]

It's not your words that make your review biased it's the idea of someone who is in love with Marvel reviewing it lower than something DC is to be expected. There's nothing wrong with that. It goes the same way in reverse for DC fans. There's not going to be an unbiased review on these boards because we're all fans of this stuff and even if we like it all, we still pick sides.

If this IMO had been better I'd say so. I've got no problem with doing that at all. It just wasn't for me and if that is biased for someone that's their deal not mine.