Captain Faramir said:
I must say, the negative reactions are a bit surprising, as it's really only the paint that's bad in my eyes.
That pretty much sums it up Cap. I think most people would agree that the base sculpt on the vast majority of Sideshow figures are phenominal, as Hunky's Aragorn proved. However, the quality of paint applications can make all of the sculpting work for nothing because the paint ends up defining the face, not the sculpt. For example, in Aragorn's factory state, his lips are a fine with a flat, focused pose, but the factory paint of his beard changes the perception and gives the appearance of an uncharacteristic smile and wider lips. The reasons paints apps are so important to people is because that head defines the character, and since most of the Sideshow figures I've seen are based off something that has a reference point to turn to, if something causes a departure from the base reference, then it becomes a bother for some. Faramir, from the neck down looks fabulous, a great piece worth adding to the collection, however, to an extent, I see issued with the face paints apps, and them giving him a look departed from the film character reference turns a Faramir figure into almost a generic LOTR character, which I'm sure is why many people are feeling let down, they wanted Faramir, but that 20% of the overall figure takes away from it's ability to give them that, where on the other side of the coin, Boromir gave us a great Sean Bean likeness and a fabulous figure to mount it on, so all around, if you bought the Boromir figure, you added it to your collection feeling you had a Boromir figure. I would wager, if you showed a LOTR fan, who knew nothing about SSC's offerings, but knew the films perfectly, the heads of Boromir and Faramir separately, Boromir would be easily identified, but Faramir would either not be spotted or take some effort to nail down.
Again, I think it's an overall great figure and I'm looking forward to getting mine, just sharing my thoughts on the importance of the heads on these figures.