Re: Hot Toys: Ellen Ripley - Alien (Updated with new prototype HS)
Yeah good job. You've made it clear that Hot Toys still has other collectors in mind.
I suppose that reduces my questions/concerns to this:
lack of completion of most obvious characters from non-MCU properties compared to lines like Iron Man 3 and Avengers
-T1 does not yet have a hero character, Kyle Reese (other than that severely outdated MMS01 figure)
-Platoon never got Elias
-Avatar never got Neytiri (arguably a more requested figure than Jake Sully even)
-Pirates of the Caribbean never got Barbossa
-Watchmen never got Rorschach (sp?)
-Back to the Future does not yet have Doc Brown (I know it's early days in a very new line but if it were an Avengers film a core character relative to Doc Brown's status would not be in doubt even at this stage)
-Batman Returns will very possibly not get Penguin and Catwoman
-X-men never gets anyone other than Wolverine
-Expendables never got anyone other than Barney Ross
-Superman the Movie never got Clark Kent (Superman Returns did, yet they pass on another Christopher Reeve figure?
)
And there are probably many more examples.
Now, sales will no doubt factor in. We're told that nothing sells as well as MCU-based figures and I reluctantly believe it. Sentimentally I want to think that my favourites are as popular today as the day they came out but I'm forced to concede that this may not be the case. However, two questions:
1) Does Hot Toys not consider that a more complete line that includes at least all the core characters (usually a pretty clear cut thing) would help sales of a given line? I would argue (without statistics I'll grant you) that a lot of people didn't buy Jake Sully because there was no indication that Neytiri was going to be made. Likewise that fewer people bought Platoon's Taylor and Barnes than otherwise would have precisely because they were waiting for Elias to be shown - never happened, now never will. It might be argued that a self-fulfilling prophecy scenario was at work here but due to previous examples of Hot Toys leaving lines incomplete at that point collectors had good reason to hesitate. Some lines just aren't worth it if there isn't going to be a full set of the major characters. True, as you've said before different people will have weird wants - 'they should make this character because he had a good scene, they should make that character because I like that actor even though he didn't have a big role' - but the core characters of a story are usually quite clearly marked out - Platoon had but 3 - Taylor, Barnes and Elias.
2) Does every figure and every line
have to make MCU levels of money to be considered worthwhile by Hot Toys? Prior to the very first MCU figure (probably Iron Man Mark III) their output of figures seemed to be doing well enough to keep them in business until they really hit the big-time. Is that kind of money really not good enough anymore that they have to be so....
tentative with non-MCU lines? Putting out 'test' figures and when it becomes apparent that those figures aren't making MCU money they drop the line which I suspect will be the case with Batman Returns. That brings me back to question 1. Do Hot Toys not think that instilling a bit more faith in collectors, giving assurances of a complete line, would help
drive sales of that line? Perhaps a vehicle is too big a gamble ('66 Batmobile, as yet up in the air) - but a figure? Especially if it's an actor they have already purchased the likeness rights for (Reeve - Clark Kent, Nicholson - further possible Joker figures)?