I really wish the figure looked as good to me in hand as it does in some of these pics.
Yeah in hand he is a different beast. I think it has to do with lighting. Vader in Empire is all about the silhouette. The HT figure has it's flaws for sure and seeing every detail up close makes him lose some of his appeal. But I do think the silhouette can be achieved. I really wish I still had my really nice digital camera. iPhone pics suck for resolution.
Also once you find a pose you like I don't want to mess around with him to repose and switch out hands. Hand switching for me is much more difficult than the RO version I had. I do wish I could put him in a more dynamic pose to go with the base, but I am pleased with the hands resting on his belt pose. Just not the pose you think of when posing him on the base he comes with, making me want to get a standard Vader stand for him that came with previous releases.
Turn down the lights and take a few steps back is the key with this figure.
And yeah, the base is really nicely done, but it's so scene specific that it is tricky to use for anything other than the hand outstretched pose.