Just came back from BvS and I really, really liked it.
It's a great movie. Better than most MCU movies, and more fun to watch than the Nolan trilogy.
There's a couple of things that had me scratching my head, but nothing that ruined the movie in any way.
All four main characters did a great job:
Luthor was quite an interesting maniac, and the hints at his troubled past were enough to give you some insight into the man.
Superman/Clark Kent was nicely developed and the character's arc was solid and interesting to watch.
Wonder Woman was mysterious and pulled off that haughty royalty thing perfectly, as well as a certain world weariness, you can tell that there is much more depth to her.
Batman/Bruce Wayne was excellent as the bitter, resentful man who sees darkness and deceit everywhere.
Special mention to Alfred, who with just a few sarcastic lines projected more love for Bruce than Caine's doddering old fool.
The action sequences were great, most notably Batman's. Superman fell a bit more into the by now usual super-human fight cliché, but the man had his cool moments. Wonder Woman looked fantastic when in kick *** mode.
I loved the music! Some very unusual pieces sprinkled among the usual heroic themes.
Cinematography was great, there were some truly beautiful moments, Snyder really does have a wonderful aesthetic.
The story itself was great; even though it felt a bit choppy at times, it never felt dull and I think Snyder handled the plot lines and the dual perspectives of Batman and Superman quite well. It wasn't an esay thing to pull off. The only parts that I felt were a bit over indulgent were the nightmare sequences, but I think that once we go into Justice League, they will be more relevant. The ending was great, I thought it was truly emotional and you could tell the audience had really been caught up in the story and characters.
So what were my issues?
I felt that Batman's crusade against Superman was a bit too forced. I couldn't quite follow him. He felt a bit too fanatical leading into the final showdown against Superman.
The main antagonist's creation felt a bit rushed, but with so much going on, it's hard to think how more time and explanation could have been given to it.
So, overall, I think it's a fantastic comic book movie and it's the kind of superhero movie I wanted to see. Unlike the fun Marvel movies, here I actually felt the heros were in danger, I felt they could get hurt, that the stakes were high.
If the critics are still bashing the hell out of this then I can only shake my head and wonder...