re: (galactiboy's Cantina) "Where everybody knows your name..."
The long-term collection and it's impact is certainly something to consider... I have a pretty large collection and I keep track of it, but if I know it would be a burden on my wife. Luckily one of my friends has already agreed (for now at least) to assist with selling off my collection should anything happen to me, and I'd do the same for him.
But what about in 20 years, and do I really want this stuff for that long
Part of me says yes, but there is a small voice that wonders if I might just be as happy with a smaller/even more focused collection.
I could see slimming down to only vintage toys, some Original Trilogy SW 1/6 figures, and a few statues and props and being content with that.
There are two things that draw me to collecting anything:
1. Tangible references to stories (generally nostalgia driven) that I love.
2. Artistry and design. I'm a designer-maker myself and have a deep appreciation for these things.
When I was much younger, childhood to early teens I guess...I collected any number of things based on my interests at the time.
Inevitably, the interest would run its course and I would purge.
From my teens onward I was most occupied with chasing girls and generally seeing what life had to offer, and my more minimalist tendencies (from my father's side no doubt) began to emerge.
In just the last few years I began to look back. Time shows you what you've outgrown, and what sticks, if only as a fond memory. Star Wars is a great example of that; I was never into the EU or the games and so on...decades have gone by without me giving the films a thought, but the OT is woven into my childhood and I love it.
Upon discovering the heights toys and collectibles had reached a few years ago, I sampled all kinds of things. Most didn't stick; the chase is always more fun than the thing in itself.
But another couple of things happened:
(a) I discovered what I really like in terms of design and execution (scale, finish, articulation etc.)
(b) I realized I have no desire to recreate scenes, sets or teams of characters. The opposite of a completist, I only want to reference the whole with some small piece that resonates with me.
Regarding that second point; Star Wars is so rich, so filled with engaging design. But what did I
need to have?
I need the hero. That's Luke.
I need to represent the technological aesthetic and a memorable bad guy. That'd be the Probe Droid and my favourite goon, the Sandtrooper.
I need a prop replica faithful to what I saw on screen. An RS Propmasters stunt helmet.
Everything else is just variations on a theme.
And that's how I decided on my Star Wars collection.
Sure, passing fancies may come and go. But to reference what I love without going overboard? That's it.
And if I fell in love with something crazy like a 1/6 TIE...I would be faced with the choice of variety vs. impact, because I wouldn't want it all. These are arbitrary choices at the end of the day, but we all make up our own rules as we go along.
As for other properties in 1/6?
Bruce Lee, Batman, Spider-Man, Iron Man. The last of which only because of Robert Downey Jr.'s entertaining portrayal and the gorgeous design of the Mark IV.
There's a ton of stuff I really like, but very little that I love. I've actually spent more time thinking about this stuff than actually acquiring it, which I guess is the most entertaining aspect of this idle hobby anyway. It's why I spend all this time geeking out on boards with fellow nerds.