Captain Faramir
Super Freak
I'll have to give on Sam. The lembas isn't something I would go gaga over as far as an exclusive. Probably should have used the Elven Cloak as the exclusive on him or done the bread, little thing the salt was in, and a couple of other little things.
That sounds like it would have been very cool. At least something more--even if it were 3 pieces of lembas instead of one. As it is, Frodo and Sam will starve before they can even make it to Ithilien.