I really like this show, or, at least, I think I do. I guess I'm kind of "on the fence," if you will. Part of me thinks that they don't know what they want the show to be, and the other part thinks that they do, and that I need to adjust to the tone. I don't know. It's almost like there are two different components. When I see a show where cops are beating confessions out of criminals, and gangsters are at war, and the title of the episode is "The Balloon Man." My first thought would be "okay, this ought to be pretty cool. They're dealing with a killer who leaves balloons at the scene of his crimes." The thought that "a guy is tying people to balloons and watching them float off into the stratosphere" never crossed my mind. I criticize some of the people who criticize TDKR because they had a different film in their mind than what they got, and I think I need to look at myself, when it comes to this show.
I think it just takes some getting used to; having a "gritty" cop show with a sense of whimsy.