Well, first of all I'm not blaming all the "hate" on one person. It's just the general vibe I'm getting from this thread.
And from one point of view, I can understand it. For Indy collectors, who have a number of Indy figs and collectibles already, this might be dissapointing because it's basically a redo of older figures, even with the Idol chamber column and everything...
But to people who don't have anything Indy in their collection, this is pretty much the figure to get. You'll get accessories which were seperate purchases back then with SS (Idol chamber environment), you'll get two iconic outfits, plus you get the best (non-custom) Indy figure out there.
So in my book, this is an awesome DX set.
I'm sure that if they hadn't included the Idol Chamber piece, people would be negative about it as well.
I'm not saying this figure is perfect, and never did. I'm sure HT could tweak the sculpt here and there to make it even more better (knowing HT they probably will), but the general negativity in this thread just comes from expectations not being met, IMO.