Okay, I will freely admit that those responses completely invalidate other things he has said in the past. Not sure why he would flip-flop so much, but I will take your word on the commentary.
However, I really don't care what he said. I won't let his flip-flopping affect the way I interpret the films. No where does it say in P1 or P2 that those guys were "kids" running around. No where in AVP does it state those Preds are "elites"/older. So, I say ignore his comments. The logic of the comics caste system works with the film, even if he doesn't agree with it.
Like I said, AVP is not a great film. However, it is an enjoyable, if average film. I am hoping for greatness with AVPR, but we will have to see what we get.
Okay, I will freely admit that those responses completely invalidate other things he has said in the past. Not sure why he would flip-flop so much, but I will take your word on the commentary.
However, I really don't care what he said. I won't let his flip-flopping affect the way I interpret the films. No where does it say in P1 or P2 that those guys were "kids" running around. No where in AVP does it state those Preds are "elites"/older. So, I say ignore his comments. The logic of the comics caste system works with the film, even if he doesn't agree with it.
Like I said, AVP is not a great film. However, it is an enjoyable, if average film. I am hoping for greatness with AVPR, but we will have to see what we get.
In the "uncut" version Alexa says directly that the Preds are teenagers. One could assume that since part of the ritual was to get their plasma casters, that the P1 and P2 Preds are older, since they already have the guns.
You could assume that, but I don't believe that to be the case.
The plasma casters they went for in AvP I think were strictly part of that hunt. It seemed like they were supposed to go to that room, get their guns, and as the last one is taken, it triggers the eggs to begin in the sacrificial chamber, and the process to begin.
I'd think since the guns were there in the beginning, if the hunt had gone right, they'd have left them there for the next group 100 years later.
Though, you could be onto something, like that they'd have to survive to earn their own gun. Who knows? I still feel like because of his weaponry, and his somewhat grizzled look, that the predator in P2 was the oldest thus far.
I do like the ancient predator though...there are two different figs of him...which one is the film accurate one? The asia one or the other one?
Do you mean the "Preds brought us Technology" part, or the "Antartica has the lost civilization" part? If the latter, it is not BS. Not provable yet, but there has been a lot of academic work and theorizing about Antartica being positioned differently and having a lost civilization akin to Atlantis. There is evidence of another lost civilization in Asia also.
But if you mean the former, yes, BS. That sort of implication really demeans what we have accomplished as humans by ourselves.
I liked AVP for what it was and that is the way we as the audience have to take films. We have to judge by what IS presented, not what we WANTED the film to be. If we all got the film we wanted, I think there would be hundreds of versions of the AVP film, running the gamut from Preds carrying teddy bears to a bloodfest that would make Manson blush. That goes with ANY film series. Hell MY version of the SW prequels would have been hella different than what we got. But then again, George didn't ask me . As to the Bishop in Alien3, not necessarily a contradiction. Perhaps the AVP Weyland had children? And the A3 was his decendant? I am reaching I know...
As far as the BD P2, I will get one and part him out, keeping the bits I want
Enter your email address to join: