The eyes are the first thing I notice about 1/6 figures and Hot Toys are miles apart from Sideshows in that respect. The doll dot certainly doesn't help them at all.
Even without the dot, I find that often, the size of the iris or the placement will be wrong for the person being painted. They often come out with generic eyes, like all the factory worries about is getting perfectly shaped little circles. It's nice to have cleanly painted eyes, but if the iris should fill up most of the eye opening and they're painted like tiny dots, it won't look like who it should be.