That is the difference between the genuine prop replica collectors and idealized prop replica collectors. There is a place for everyone.
For me nothing will beat a replica that looks exactly like the original made for the movies, especially since I won't be able to afford real screen used props - and I don't mean some insignificant tiny prop, or one of a million Death Star tiles available out there, but big props like a screen-used helmet, a studio scale ship, a movie used blaster or lightsaber etc. This way even with a replica (made like the original) I can see its wonderful details and its asymmetric perfection.
Of course Lucas would have wanted that everything was perfect for the universe he created, but the beauty here is the use of regular found items to add up to certain props. You can see how they used faucet aerators for mic tips on Stormtrooper helmets, Tamyia parts on the snout of the Scout helmets, various screws still can be seen on the studio scale AT-AT (even on the MR versions), many model parts (mostly from model tanks) used on all studio scale ships, lightsabers made entirely of a vintage Graflex or MPP camera flash or a WWI British rifle grenade, blasters made of real WWII guns with added tanks scopes and other greeblies.
This only shows the talent, ingenuity and creativity of the gifted prop makers who worked for Star Wars back then. Without their professional inventiveness and skills we would not have had the Star Wars we know and love, the "used universe" we got familiar with, and which is so different from all other sci-fi universes out there. These ugly asymmetrical props were part of this used, but such real universe, where ships, buildings, and props alike looked aged and dirty.
That is why I totally prefer my props to be ugly, asymmetrical, wonky, etc., because they were like this when used in Star Wars. I don't mind explaining someone why a prop is like that, it is in fact my pleasure to show them how the real Star Wars was created, and how proud I am to own a tiny piece of this universe.