As a figure the Wasteland Ranger is a better figure, but there are things about the Mad/Crazy Racer that I think look more "screen" accurate. There are Hardyesque aspects on the Mad Racer sculpt but it isn't great. A swap would help.
As far as this newer Max goes it's workable. It is still the best sculpt of the three, but that's not saying much. I think how you feel about the figure will depend on how much they messed up on your individual figure. I hate the fact that my leg brace doesn't not have a straight edge.
Both "Max's" arrived today. I did not set up them but just took a quick look at them with initial impressions being the key.
The Mad/Crazy Racer arrived first and to be honest, I was pleasantly surprised with it. While I think I prefer the VTS sculpt, mostly for the hair sculpt, there is enough Tom Hardy in this one that I can wait a while before addressing that aspect.
The Wasteland Warrior arrived just a few minutes ago. I was expecting a train wreck and while not a great rendition, I have to admit that it has enough decent parts to help offset some of the negatives.
Every critique previously mentioned by everyone is absolutely correct and applicable, especially when posed next to another figure, for scale comparisons. For example, the head sculpt could have been a little larger and the body used should have been better than a 1/6 Hasbro body from the 1990's. It definitely will be immediately replaced. And yet, when the figure is looked at alone, it doesn't suck...
The sculpt and most likely accentuated by the paint apps, make it look like a caricature of the character. It is easily recognizable but there's an obvious cartoony-ness to it. Will eventually require a replacement, for sure.
I haven't done a deep dive on either figure and the accessories yet but first impressions were good on the Mad/Crazy Racer (unsure why I'm including his review here except for the fact that he was also arriving today) and not as bad as expected, on the Wasteland Ranger.
Final analysis: The real question is: Was he worth the money? Well, as I don't have any previous rendition of the character and its one of my grails, I suppose he was worth it. But because he is a grail, I'll be throwing additional money into it, in order to get it to a level that I can really be happy with it. If you are looking for a quick representation of "Road Warrior" Max, then I can definitely recommend it. It's definitely a Mel Max that will be displayed on your shelf.
A few quick and crappy pics...