PS4 OR Xbox One?

Collector Freaks Forum

Help Support Collector Freaks Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

?


  • Total voters
    534
  • Poll closed .
Exactly, and more importantly, when you don't check in for over 24hrs, your PC doesn't turn into a $500 paper weight.

This is a stumbling block I will fully admit. It's the one thing that is not quite right. I don't mind the actual check in, it's the consequences of not checking in.

It's bizarre and possibly (hopefully) this will be changed.

Apart from that though I get though whole DRM - digital games, lower prices, better games, convenience, don't get ripped off from gamestop - thing.

It does have a lot of "potential" plus sides. I'll give it a chance.
 
It's not about being able to afford things or not.

It's about them taking away your options and your ownership.

It's not about MS going into the future, who's to say Sony is not aiming towards the future? If you think fancy voice commands are the future, you're easily impressionable and you've never opened a sci-fi novel.

I'm all in for anti piracy measures, but when anti-piracy measure and used games become the scapegoat for something else.... then no.
 
Yes of course? Reading quotes from George Lucas/Steven Spielberg the prediction is for movie's to keep going up and up in price until it becomes a novelty. Why? Because of mass piracy and dwindling numbers. You're telling me all those guy's with PC's are all red roses? No piracy or hacking going on?! :lol It's not just that either. If this is the way they see the technology going, who's to stop them? Just don't buy it if you don't want it. If you're not doing anything wrong there's nothing to worry about right?

I only brought up the military because you used it like some kind of slander against MS. I respect the military fully and the lives the save. Do I care that they can't play an X-box at dinner time? :lol How stupid does that sound really. Why is it even a "thing". I can't play my X-box on my mine site on my 2 weeks shift, does that mean I should make a stand against MS too? It's a completely retarded and irrelevant subject.



I'm not even sure what this means to be honest. I've made my points clear. I'm still not even siding with PS4 or MS either. I'm presenting the evidence and how it effects me.

Right now the DRM is not a big deal for me personally. If you can afford an XB1 there's a hella good chance you've got the internet. :slap
To me, your position boiled down to "it doesn't affect me, therefore, who cares that it affects anyone". I used the military because they are the most recognizable example. I can instead point out the people I know in other countries who will be completely left out, if that helps, although I was thinking some here would dismiss them as "insignificant" people.

It's a "thing" because MS is screwing over a part of their fanbase. You don't have to care, and you obviously don't, but some of us think it's a bad idea.

Piracy is a problem, and if you think this is the solution, then good for you, that's your opinion and I respect that, even though I disagree.

About your "hivemind" comment...so if something seems like a crappy idea to a lot of people, it's just jumping the bandwagon? Or maybe it really is an immensely crappy idea to a large quantity of people.

We do see the "big picture", and that picture leaves out a lot of people, including those who are decades away from having the connections you and I enjoy. It's a "big picture" of DRM controlled software, where you don't own your game, and some people will have to give up console gaming entirely. There are many possible futures, what MS is doing isn't the only way it can go.

We aren't protesting your decision to love the Xbox One, we're simply vocalizing what we disagree with, and we disagree with how the policies treat certain less fortunate gamers. If we just stay quiet, how will anyone know many consumers don't agree with it?

About my last line, I wanted an answer directly from you, which I didn't get last time, so thanks for replying to me directly.

EDIT: And I see you disagree with the lock out if you can't check in, so we're completely on the same page there.
 
Last edited:
I like how you just completely skip over the fact that you pretty much said only poor people don't have internet. Are you against the military or something?

Show me that quote.

I can't communicate with you dude sorry. It's not a discussion about X-box vs PS which is why I am here. Plus you seem to be incapable of reading clearly.

Back on topic...
 
Now it turns out MS are some sort of vanguard prophets innovating and aiming towards the future....

wtf-eccbc87e4b5ce2fe28308fd9f2a7baf3-2530.gif
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Show me that quote.

I can't communicate with you dude sorry. It's not a discussion about X-box vs PS which is why I am here. Plus you seem to be incapable of reading clearly.

Back on topic...

I'm not going to go back and find your quote, but you clearly stated something along the lines as who cares that the military can't play I don't get to use my cell phone at work. Then just a little bit ago you said Everything is "Oh the military" ...."Oh the poor people" Why does it bother you so much that people are wanting our troops to be able to play xbox? My old room mate was overseas for a year and you know what they did on their free time? They played Halo, but now they wouldn't be able to. So its not just the whole get a PS4 thing, because they shouldn't have to be forced into getting one system, because the other one has so many strict settings. Even Microsoft said well your in a sub? Get a 360. ****ing jackasses. Oh and I never said you said you hated the military. I was just asking you a simple question. So I guess I'm not the one who can't read clearly.
 
To me, your position boiled down to "it doesn't affect me, therefore, who cares that it affects anyone".

It will not effect the majority of XBL customers. If it does they have another option. MS have obviously crunched the numbers. I can't get access to Amazon/Streaming Radio, all the fancy jazz Americans get. I don't complain - because I can't get it - simple. :)

It's a "thing" because MS is screwing over a part of their fanbase. You don't have to care, and you obviously don't, but some of us think it's a bad idea.

They are not screwing over anyone. They are offering a product that has certain limitations that most of the world can get past. Much like how an Iphone only works with a phone siginal. I'm still not sure what's hard to understand about that. Should we always try to make technology accessible to 6 billion? Or should we advance the technology further so we can get to that state someday?

Piracy is a problem

If Piracy get's cut = better cheaper games for everyone, not just the pirates.

About your "hivemind" comment...so if something seems like a crappy idea to a lot of people, it's just jumping the bandwagon?

Of course not but PS and a lot of fans have piggy backed on a lot of false and unconfirmed details. As far as I can see the 24 hour check in is the one major fail but going around the internet you would think they made the XB1 out of chip wood. Having read a few "Engineer" articles it seems they fully understand the potential of the DRM and XB1.

We do see the "big picture", and that picture leaves out a lot of people, who are decades away from having the connections you and I enjoy. It's a "big picture" of DRM controlled software, where you don't own your game, and some people will have to give up console gaming entirely.

No they won't. By all accounts the PS4 will work for them. XB are breaking off. Competition is good, it means we get a better product.

We aren't protesting your decision to love the Xbox One

Again, you're not reading my posts. My initial jump into this thread was to discuss the fact that on paper - not from fanboys mouths - both consoles seem to be very capable of great things but right now the PS4 holds the edge with potentially the XB1 being the better long term investment IF they can clear up some of the details.

I may have to put this in my signature.
 
Good god, you're really high on the MS Kool-Aid, aren't you?

Just taking in the facts and having a think :wink1:

I own both systems right now. I've never been a "fanboy". Too much good stuff out there to limit yourself to one product.

This time round though I think to gain the most out of the system it will be better to stick to one line since it can obviously do lots more than the current models.

I guess it may come down to if you ONLY play games or you want to do a bit more.
 
I've preordered the PS4 launch bundle from Amazon.

And please, enlighten me why the XBone is the better long term investment, Solar.
 
It will not effect the majority of XBL customers. If it does they have another option. MS have obviously crunched the numbers. I can't get access to Amazon/Streaming Radio, all the fancy jazz Americans get. I don't complain - because I can't get it - simple. :)



They are not screwing over anyone. They are offering a product that has certain limitations that most of the world can get past. Much like how an Iphone only works with a phone siginal. I'm still not sure what's hard to understand about that. Should we always try to make technology accessible to 6 billion? Or should we advance the technology further so we can get to that state someday?



If Piracy get's cut = better cheaper games for everyone, not just the pirates.



Of course not but PS and a lot of fans have piggy backed on a lot of false and unconfirmed details. As far as I can see the 24 hour check in is the one major fail but going around the internet you would think they made the XB1 out of chip wood. Having read a few "Engineer" articles it seems they fully understand the potential of the DRM and XB1.



No they won't. By all accounts the PS4 will work for them. XB are breaking off. Competition is good, it means we get a better product.



Again, you're not reading my posts. My initial jump into this thread was to discuss the fact that on paper - not from fanboys mouths - both consoles seem to be very capable of great things but right now the PS4 holds the edge with potentially the XB1 being the better long term investment IF they can clear up some of the details.

I may have to put this in my signature.
I like how you say most of the world can get past the whole internet thing. Its not that easy. Is the internet offered around here? Absolutely, but that doesn't mean that people can actually get it. Anyone that lives a mile outside of town will not be getting an xbox. You know how many friends of mine that affects? ALOT. Cell phones are so much different than consoles. Towers reach a long distance and their are a ton of them. People out in the country can still get phone service even if its ****ty they just might have to only call from one part of the house. Can't say the same thing about the internet. Sure they can get dial up, but in no way will that allow them to be able to play the xbox.

I would say Piracy is the worst on PC. Reason is because its way easier to pirate a game for the PC. Yet Steam, Origin, Uplay, Amazon all have incredible and I really mean incredible deals on games. Green Man gaming is probably the best place to get new release games reason is because they are that much cheaper than buying anywhere else. I don't see consoles getting those kind of deals when new games are released. So I highly doubt we will see better and cheaper games with the xbox.
 
It will not effect the majority of XBL customers. If it does they have another option. MS have obviously crunched the numbers. I can't get access to Amazon/Streaming Radio, all the fancy jazz Americans get. I don't complain - because I can't get it - simple. :)



They are not screwing over anyone. They are offering a product that has certain limitations that most of the world can get past. Much like how an Iphone only works with a phone siginal. I'm still not sure what's hard to understand about that. Should we always try to make technology accessible to 6 billion? Or should we advance the technology further so we can get to that state someday?



If Piracy get's cut = better cheaper games for everyone, not just the pirates.



Of course not but PS and a lot of fans have piggy backed on a lot of false and unconfirmed details. As far as I can see the 24 hour check in is the one major fail but going around the internet you would think they made the XB1 out of chip wood. Having read a few "Engineer" articles it seems they fully understand the potential of the DRM and XB1.



No they won't. By all accounts the PS4 will work for them. XB are breaking off. Competition is good, it means we get a better product.



Again, you're not reading my posts. My initial jump into this thread was to discuss the fact that on paper - not from fanboys mouths - both consoles seem to be very capable of great things but right now the PS4 holds the edge with potentially the XB1 being the better long term investment IF they can clear up some of the details.

I may have to put this in my signature.
I see your position clearer now. It's really a difference of opinion on what it means to, in my words, "screw over" a customer. I felt the DRM is harsh and unnecessary to fans of the MS franchises and gamers with bad/non-existent connections, but once again, that also comes down to our difference in opinion on how to fight piracy, and whether or not certain people must be left out in order to accomplish that (I obviously don't think so). But I agree that they can simply move to another console.

And about giving up console gaming, I worded that poorly, I meant if the vision MS has for Xbox One becomes the standard for all consoles, then it would shut out people entirely. Once again, I agree that in the present, they can just move to another console to avoid that, and I agree competition is a great thing.

You call the 24 hour check in a "major fail", and I couldn't agree more. I won't address some of the other comments you made, it's just a difference of opinion, and I'm not trying to change your mind.

I've read all your posts, but I really just wanted you to clarify your comments on the military and people with bad connections. A lot of insulting things are being said by MS fans, and it's real ugly and unnecessary. So if you don't feel the same way as they do, then I'm happy for you.
 
Last edited:
I see your position clearer now. It's really a difference of opinion on what it means to, in my words, "screw over" a customer. I felt the DRM is harsh and unnecessary to fans of the MS franchises and gamers with bad/non-existent connections, but once again, that also comes down to our difference in opinion on how to fight piracy, and whether or not certain people must be left out in order to accomplish that (I obviously don't think so). But I agree that they can simply move to another console.

And about giving up console gaming, I worded that poorly, I meant if the vision MS has for Xbox One becomes the standard for all consoles, then it would shut out people entirely. Once again, I agree they can just move to another console to avoid that, and I agree competition is a great thing.

You call the 24 hour check in a "major fail", and I couldn't agree more.

I've read all your posts, but I wanted you to clarify your comments on the military and people with bad connections. A lot of insulting things are being said by MS fans, and it's real ugly and unnecessary. So if you don't feel the same way as they do, then I'm happy for you.

:exactly::goodpost:
 
And please, enlighten me why the XBone is the better long term investment, Solar.

Well from my initial impressions, the PS4 is a gaming monster where as the XB1 seems to be more like a home entertainment system with gaming. With the advances in Televisions, 3D, cabling updates, signal changes happening at a really frantic pace now, the XB1 could be gearing it self up for more industry wide changes or future compatibility (that's not to say PS4 wouldn't be either).

Of course this is only speculation on my part but from the (sane) articles I've read most tech savvy people seem to think the XB1 has it's eye's on bigger things than just pure gaming.

A lot of insulting things are being said by MS fans, and it's real ugly and unnecessary.

The same can be said for PS fans. In fact there's a certain "smugness" going around the internet from that camp like they some how won the war. It's pointless. Siding with a group or insulting people because of their allegiance is just plain dumb. I don't care for it at all. Most intelligent gamers can identify the system for them without having to resort to frothy internet arguments. I've been doing it for 25 years :lol

I like how you say most of the world can get past the whole internet thing. Its not that easy.

Majority rules. This will be the way and has always been the way. I can't get 4G internet and live very far away from the exchange. I make do with what is given to me. No use complaining about it. Australia does not even a have a national broadband system yet.....:horror

Plus we will pay $150 more for each console on release than the rest of the world and around $20-30 more for games. Is that fair? Some things are just crap and unavoidable. :lecture
 
The same can be said for PS fans. In fact there's a certain "smugness" going around the internet from that camp like they some how won the war. It's pointless. Siding with a group or insulting people because of their allegiance is just plain dumb. I don't care for it at all. Most intelligent gamers can identify the system for them without having to resort to frothy internet arguments. I've been doing it for 25 years :lol
I've also owned all the systems, and I couldn't care less about fanboy arguments. The comments from MS fanboys I was referring to were ones directed at the military and people with bad connections, basically stuff like "who cares about those people/that country", "if they're poor they don't deserve to play console games anyway", things of that nature.

Your initial comments read in a similar way to me, and I was hoping you could clarify your actual position, since saying "who cares" doesn't convey anything other than arrogance. I think you've made yourself clear now, to some extent.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top