Rogue One: A Star Wars Story (12/16/16) *SPOILERS*

[Wor-Gar]

I got dem Harmy's last year

What ya get, what ya get? 2.5s? Art case? What?

 

[DiFabio]

I don't like the name "Harmy".

 

[Wor-Gar]

Well what would you like?

*said Solo*

 

[jye4ever]

B&R easily > BF

Both suck but one makes me laugh.

When i'm in the mood for 66 TV show with big budget effects I put on B&R.

When I want to remember the needle still in the arm junkie hooker who was sitting on a dirty toilet with her still connected newborn inside the toilet I put on BF.

 

[The Clown Prince of Crime]

B&R easily > BF

I like Batman Forever. Kilmer had the best voice, decent fight scenes, and a nice sense of humor.

The Riddler and Two Face looked cool and were fun to watch.

B&R is a good comedy in retrospect, like Commando.

 

[jye4ever]

Commando easily > BF

Kidman was hot though.

 

[a-dev]

Even if you disregard Vader killing children in Episode III and the prequels completely, it's still silly how Vader gets a Force ghost and is "redeemed" in the end. If you don't take into account ROTS and RO, he is still unredeemable.


- betrayed and hunted down the Jedi, killing them
- killed the Tantive IV captain
- tortured Prince Leia
- conspired with Tarkin and was an accomplice in the death of billions
- killed Obi-Wan Kenobi when he lowered his defenses
- shot X-Wing fighters in the back and killed the pilots, including Luke's best friend, Biggs
- trapped and imprisoned Luke's friends
- tortured Han Solo
- wounded his own son and cut off his hand
- killed his own officers
- sold his soul to the Emperor as his slave
- provoked his son to lash out at him so he'd kill him and take his place as the Emperor's new ***** boy
- stands by for almost a full minute as his own son is suffering and getting fried


Nobody should feel sorry for Vader and he definitely shouldn't have gotten that goofy smiling Force ghost. Vader took part in torture, murder and genocide. Killing a room of kids is just a cherry on top.

Well what would you like?

*said Solo*

I understood that reference. <- itself a reference waheyy!!!

Kidman was hot though.

I did not appreciate that at the time. My favourite is when her hair is tied up and she's boxing.

 

[DiFabio]

 

[The Clown Prince of Crime]

I did not appreciate that at the time. My favourite is when her hair is tied up and she's boxing.

Yes, and wearing that tight outfit

 

[DiFabio]

Nicole Kidman > Kim Basinger > Michelle Pfeiffer > Marion Cotillard > Anne Hathaway > Katie Holmes > Elle Macpherson >Maggie Gylenhall

 

[Prime Clone]

There was a rumour a couple of years back that Schumacher's planned third film Batman Triumphant would be released as a graphic novel. Alas it was false.

 

[Centurion]

Nicole Kidman > Kim Basinger > Michelle Pfeiffer > Marion Cotillard > Anne Hathaway > Katie Holmes > Elle Macpherson >Maggie Gylenhall

Those were just Batman's accessories.

 

[Prime Clone]

Just because the Geonocians had a design doesn't make them the architect. Right? So even then, I don't see it as having ever been canon that the Geonocians were the architects. Seems like they were Separatists go to factory workers. If that makes sense,

That's my story and I'm sticking to it.

You're probably right. Geonosis was probably just the Trade Federation's main foundry world. Whereas the Kaminoans both designed and built the clones.

The DS appears to be an evolution of the Trade Federation battle ships that are one of the first things we see in the whole saga (if you watch it in episodic order).

In TPM they are spheres with rings around them, by the time of AOTC we see them on the surface of Geonosis without the rings. So the DS is just a supersized version of these.

Then the Empire comes along and makes some "special modifications" of its own.

Palpatine's divide-and-conquer plan was ingenious cos he inherited the military tech from both sides.

 

[jye4ever]

Didn't the clones shoot down a DS in AOTC.


Maggie is a hot milf.

 

[Centurion]

Didn't the clones shoot down a DS in AOTC.

That was actually a Death Star testicle:

 

[Prime Clone]

Yup! The smaller-sized forerunner.

Reminds me of my fave Yoda quote ever: "Around the survivors a perimeter create"!

 

[jye4ever]

I got worried when I saw the shield ship in RO because it immediately reminded me of that TF ship.

ESB Yoda quotes are his best.

 

[Prime Clone]

Hehe, by "fave" I meant "not fave".

 

[jye4ever]

That was actually a Death Star testicle:

 

[Prime Clone]

RO says otherwise because it's a "replacement prequel." One of the reasons they didn't post a scroll was probably because they didn't want to call out that they were the "new" Episode III nor did they want to spell out in several paragraphs any mention of prequel events (since again, they weren't acknowledging them and were instead contradicting them.)

Nah, none of the anthology films will have the scroll because they're not major "episodes". That's also why "Star Wars" is relegated to the subtitle.

Ironically it's the Empire itself, not the filmmakers, who erase the Geonosian link: in the new canon the surface of the planet is "sterilised" to remove all evidence.

RO might skirt around the Geonosian link but Rebels tackles it head-on, and it's canon too.

There's no good reason not to accept that the plans came from Geonosis and were then adapted by the Empire.