Star Wars: Episode IX - THE RISE OF SKYWALKER

Collector Freaks Forum

Help Support Collector Freaks Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Well thats not what it looked like in the movie.. And i could care less what Disney says unless its on the screen.. So will go that the force projection killed him.. Because the other ideas is Stupid :lol

It looked like horse **** in the movie too kind of like the explanation for palps surviving the fall and having a son while he doesnt have a **** and is stuck on that device (so disney comes out and says his son was a clone). Luke literally just looked up at the sun and disappeared on the rock- how can we infer anything from that? Lol

This is why disney had to come out and make an official statement of what happened cause nobody knows based on what we saw lol. There was nothing conclusive about that- it was vague as ****
 
What about Kyoto’s line “the strain alone would kill him”?

Obviously He was wrong he was doing that with rey the whole time (they even battled through projections), not to mention snoke/palps was able to bridge minds and that is what kylo was referring too. He didnt die from that **** either

They just put that line in there to explain why this new force power wasnt seen in the older movies it was “too risky” cause only certain users had the power to do it safely. I guess you wouldnt know until you tried so it was banned by jedi during the pt
 
She mentioned that in TFA, she might be a Kenobi. Then in TLJ she was nobody. Then the third movie, your right, she thought maybe Palpatine granddaughter, but they were rushing through the movie so quick, she thought they had changed it again. She didn't know until release what they were going to go with.

Even if she'd really understood it - what the hell does it even mean? "Palps is your Granddad"?

"Vader is your father" has all kinds of connections, power and complexity.

Palps as grandad just suggests a JJ committee sitting around a conference table for days with a big white board with random **** scribbled out connecting to anyone the fan mob would go "ahhh..." for: "Obi Wan's granddaughter? Yoda's foster child? How about Wedge and Biggs - gay couple adoption?"

And after two days JJ's hottie-non-gendered intern calls out "hey, how about that old white man in the robe from Return of the Sith, I think from the 80s?!" and everyone went "Oooo..."
 
Even if she'd really understood it - what the hell does it even mean? "Palps is your Granddad"?

"Vader is your father" has all kinds of connections, power and complexity.

Palps as grandad just suggests a JJ committee sitting around a conference table for days with a big white board with random **** scribbled out connecting to anyone the fan mob would go "ahhh..." for: "Obi Wan's granddaughter? Yoda's foster child? How about Wedge and Biggs - gay couple adoption?"

And after two days JJ's hottie-non-gendered intern calls out "hey, how about that old white man in the robe from Return of the Sith, I think from the 80s?!" and everyone went "Oooo..."
....
3facf5910d298d2e3ace00540c7c6302.gif
d30f771a1f437c9158c1f98b061ef73a.gif


Sent from my SM-G975U1 using Tapatalk
 
At some point the "daughter of a clone" option must have been pretty solid because it made it into the novelization! Unless the author was just told to make something up (and came up with something better than any of them :))
 
Just as your sig proudly proclaims, story group approved! :lol

Here's my LFL team in the actual process of coming up with that board at Skywalker Ranch, and I ran a highlighter under the points that I gave them extra cred for.:lecture

M0gegdY.jpg


9dRUHq0.png


And yes, I did give them kudos for listing diversity in the top five twice on the same board.

I did however reprimand them for placing dinosaurs above representation.
 
I never understood the 'University' note under wishes. Star Wars University is a wish?

Nor why 'Feelings" is listed under 'Fiction'.


That board makes me mad... but not as mad as your avatar.

































I dream of Jannah.jpg
 
Last edited:
Not pro-war... but must have space and lightsaber battles!

And must be called Star Wars.

Once again, Lucas did all this years ago with Anakin’s “aggressive negotiations”.
 
Why is the force at the bottom of the list.... it's the connective tissue that literally binds the Star Wars universe.

Rival house made me laugh, clearly just been watching game of thrones. Dinosaurs, that would be on my list when I was seven years old but clearly, so clearly, not needed in Star Wars where you have the creative freedom to make up any species that can pop into your head. It reads like a list made by a group of nincompoops who may have seen one of those Star Wars flicks that one time (the prominence given to 'droids' and 'space' sheesh!) who then rushed to throw in things that are hot right now (in the hopes that they can capture some of that shine) but most prevalence and focus given to their own ideology.

'High republic' is clearly a buzz phrase that is going around the office because of the new project but I bet most in that meeting have no idea when that time period is supposed to have occurred (and 'lived in' is the opposite of that period as the wealthy areas would look opulent, like the PT but even shinier).

I'm sitting here in my home office littered with Star Wars memorabilia with a Jedi Luke and Boba Fett figures from my childhood sitting on my desk and a freakin Bossk black series figure staring at me as I type. I have a vast knowledge of Star Wars and the 'expanded universe' having watched the movies (pre-disney) so many times, I've consumed the tv shows/cartoons books, comics and games (though none of the new ST stuff) and I'm not alone in this madness (passion lol) as there are many many people like me or with more knowledge than me out there - however, there appear to be so few of us in the creative roles at LucasFilm (no offence to your team Talibane :)).

If someone took a picture of me in my work space right now and said I worked in the lucasfilm 'story group' (or just at LFL in any team) from a less diverse time I suggest that no one would question it or eye roll (well they would probably eye roll but for reasons other than disbelief that I have that job).

It makes me shake my head ... How can they (or perhaps a better question should be why are they so willing to) not find qualified people out there with a love for the source material to fill those roles.

Meditate on this I will.
 
Last edited:
I never understood the 'University' note under wishes. Star Wars University is a wish?

Nor why 'Feelings" is listed under 'Fiction'.


That board makes me mad... but not as mad as your avatar.

Yup - it makes any common-sense thinking SW fan mad.

I loved everything about Hollywood growing up; it was inspiring and ground breaking in so many ways.

Now Hollyweird is a vapid, unimaginative, box-ticking, bunch of KPI driven embarrassments, that have no right to be handling old IP's.

I would have given my left leg to work in the industry back in the day, but now you couldn't pay me any amount of money to dance like a monkey for those ****wits.
 
I never understood the 'University' note under wishes. Star Wars University is a wish?

Nor why 'Feelings" is listed under 'Fiction'.


That board makes me mad... but not as mad as your avatar.

View attachment 495000

I wanted a "university" entry because our beloved Hogwarts 3 had just united against J.K. Rowlingemort and her violent hate masquerading as common sense.

My actual note was to call it "Rancormoles School of Sithcraft and Space Wizardry" which the group thought sounded really fresh/unique, but it was simply noted as "University" for short.

Why is the force at the bottom of the list.... it's the connective tissue that literally binds the Star Wars universe.

Rival house made me laugh, clearly just been watching game of thrones. Dinosaurs, that would be on my list when I was seven years old but clearly, so clearly, not needed in Star Wars where you have the creative freedom to make up any species that can pop into your head. It reads like a list made by a group of nincompoops who may have seen one of those Star Wars flicks that one time (the prominence given to 'droids' and 'space' sheesh!) who then rushed to throw in things that are hot right now (in the hopes that they can capture some of that shine) but most prevalence and focus given to their own ideology.

'High republic' is clearly a buzz phrase that is going around the office because of the new project but I bet most in that meeting have no idea when that time period is supposed to have occurred (and 'lived in' is the opposite of that period as the wealthy areas would look opulent, like the PT but even shinier).

I'm sitting here in my home office littered with Star Wars memorabilia with a Jedi Luke and Boba Fett figures from my childhood sitting on my desk and a freakin Bossk black series figure staring at me as I type. I have a vast knowledge of Star Wars and the 'expanded universe' having watched the movies (pre-disney) so many times, I've consumed the tv shows/cartoons books, comics and games (though none of the new ST stuff) and I'm not alone in this madness (passion lol) as there are many many people like me or with more knowledge than me out there - however, there appear to be so few of us in the creative roles at LucasFilm (no offence to your team Talibane :)).

If someone took a picture of me in my work space right now and said I worked in the lucasfilm 'story group' (or just at LFL in any team) from a less diverse time I suggest that no one would question it or eye roll (well they would probably eye roll but for reasons other than disbelief that I have that job).

It makes me shake my head ... How can they (or perhaps a better question should be why are they so willing to) not find qualified people out there with a love for the source material to fill those roles.

Meditate on this I will.

You are SO de-platformed, b***h.:lecture

Yup - it makes any common-sense thinking SW fan mad.

I loved everything about Hollywood growing up; it was inspiring and ground breaking in so many ways.

Now Hollyweird is a vapid, unimaginative, box-ticking, bunch of KPI driven embarrassments, that have no right to be handling old IP's.

I would have given my left leg to work in the industry back in the day, but now you couldn't pay me any amount of money to dance like a monkey for those ****wits.

That's why I love the new Academy/Oscars rules for Best Picture - when you forged the pitchforks, started the fire and hand-raised the mobs, don't be surprised when they turn and march on your castle keep too.

After the craziness of the past few months, my guess is the Academy's ivory tower was literally expecting near-violent mobs/protests at the 2021 Oscars early next year so decided head them off at the pass and go woke - and I mean the kind of woke that has open eyes painted on your eyelids.
 
That's why I love the new Academy/Oscars rules for Best Picture - when you forged the pitchforks, started the fire and hand-raised the mobs, don't be surprised when they turn and march on your castle keep too.

After the craziness of the past few months, my guess is the Academy's ivory tower was literally expecting near-violent mobs/protests at the 2021 Oscars early next year so decided head them off at the pass and go woke - and I mean the kind of woke that has open eyes painted on your eyelids.

Celebrities only want normal people's dinner parties interrupted, not their own. Same deal with politicians. They don't give a damn about other people's property and businesses, but immediately draw a line in the sand when it's their home that is threatened. The Oscars are nothing but a venue for them all to backslap each other on phony job well done.
 
It reads like a list made by a group of nincompoops...

:lol

That it does. Some strange effort to break down Star Wars into digestible parts ... but like a 5 year old would do -- space battles and droids. I don't even understand the intent behind that board. Is it a plan, is it a way to focus, is it literally a grocery list for the development people to "think on"? All those people should be way beyond this type of novice approach. Dinosaurs? Actual ending? University? Surprise? Is it any wonder we got what we got?

Oh, and I think Talibane got it right: University is probably some lame attempt to cash in on Hogwarts. This is what the brilliant development minds at LFL think -- kids love Potter, kids love dinosaurs, etc... Its sooooooo Disney, it is sickening.

To me, the Broom Boy "when you wish upon a star" ending was the ultimate slap in the face into Disneyfying Star Wars. Beyond insulting.

I was surprised that Babu Frick didn't become a Jimmy Cricket character to someone.
 
Wait was the board legit lol i thought it was a meme or joke board. No wonder it was a mess they, needed gl in that room to fix all those lists then hire a director to reign georges ideas in. Kk says its hard to create new stories well you had a man full of stories you used to work with but you refused to take his help or listen to him. You wanted to steal the spotlight of star wars from him (she reminds me of johns at dc) and you failed miserably.

JF and Df consult gl on all their projects (mando and clone wars) because unlike kk they are both humble enough and smart enough to know that only fool would not listen or heed the advice of the creator of this world. He has so many stories and so much written ****ing use him, not only would it make him feel good that you ask him for ideas and help but you will end up with a better stars wars product in the long run. They better get all the info they can from this man before he dies otherwise star wars is dead in disneys hands, esp when the main person in charge says its too hard to create original stories since there is no source to draw from Like marvel comics lol ya there is ***** but you saw an opportunity to take over star wars and steal his thunder after the pt killed his rep a bit, she thought she knew better then gl, but it all backfired on her ass- kharma is a mother****er

Game of throwns is a perfect example as soon as they had no more book material to go on and they had to create their own **** to end the series it was ****ing terrible. Season 8 was so bad that it reminded me of the st in terms of character continuity and plot holes. however in thier case they had no choice cause Martin hadn't finished the books, but it does illustrate how dumb kk was for not using george Lucas at all when he would have gladly helped. In fact she went out of her way to diss him, he gave her a bunch of stuff but she intentionally ignored and scrapped nearly all of it which is why he was so heartbroken after seeing tfa. I will say though he must have liked tfa more then the other 2 cause he didnt say a peep about those two atrocities that followed outside of confirming that jj did indeed call him to ask for his input on tros
 
Back
Top