But the ST is better then the PT.
I actually agree with your statement... But where is the fun in that
Star Wars: Episode IX - THE RISE OF SKYWALKER
- Thread starter CallMeTheDoctor
- Start date
Help Support Collector Freaks Forum:
But the ST is better then the PT.
I actually agree with your statement... But where is the fun in that
jye4ever
Broke and happy
I?m ready for round 17,664 lol
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
jye4ever
Broke and happy
Oh snap has anyone listened to the Knives Out commentary by RJ.
He said that his biggest regret was not being able to test screen TLJ due to the tight security even with NDA being used Disney will never allow it with SW.
He said the audience reactions and feedback could?ve helped him.
Interesting.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
He said that his biggest regret was not being able to test screen TLJ due to the tight security even with NDA being used Disney will never allow it with SW.
He said the audience reactions and feedback could?ve helped him.
Interesting.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
"I... I saw a movie in the toilet."
"Mmm... fans you put there..."
"They were in pain."
"It is the future you see."
"Will they hate it?"
"Difficult to see without test screenings. Always in motion is the Disney stock price."
I think I?m gearing toward getting the digital release over the blu ray for now
Still contemplating...don?t judge me
The digital release looks great but the upcoming 4K disc is supposedly reference quality.
https://thedigitalbits.com/item/star-wars-the-rise-of-skywalker-uhd
Here is the scene.. If you have no issues with it that's fine.. No problem.. I see all sorts of issues.. The awful Saber duel, Sam Jackson's "He's the Traitor" and his grown of struggle, Palps awful faces, Anakin's entrance in the room (What a strange take)..
The goofy back and forth between Mace and Palps
Palps "Kill him Anakin he's a traitor"
Mace "He's the Traitor"
Mace "He's too dangerous to keep alive"
Palps "I'm too weak"
Palps "You're dumb"
Mace "No you're Dumb"
How about "No. No. No. No..." Delivery.
Sam Jacksons scream when he gets his arm cut off. I imagine that is hard for an actor who has played a bad ass his entire career to scream in pain. So I understand
Anakin is perfectly consistently boring.
Other then moments in TLJ there is noting in the ST that is consistently cringe worthy that goes on for as long as that scene.. And that is supposed to be a huge moment of the film... I did not even add the original Palps duel with the 4 jedi.. Yikes..
All that stuff just really took me out of the film... Just like Canto Bight and Haldo did in TLJ.
But I can still watch it and find some enjoyment out of it.. It feels more like SW then TFA and TLJ.. Its not as well made as either film but it does feel like SW.. Other then the final Saber duel, I hate the look and feel of TFA. TLJ looks better but as a whole.. Meh.
The no no no delivery was great, dude went full sith lord crazy badass then UNLIMTED POWAHHHHHHHHH
Way more emotion and realistic than that terrible Bespin Luke no scream. The “goofy” back and forth was a ploy from Palpatine to make Anakin buy into the Jedi being traitors. I don’t see anything wrong with the delivery and Mace was right, Palpatine was too dangerous to be kept alive. Palpatine’s “I’m too weak... can’t hold it... too weak” lines were to get Anakin to step in.
Like I said, only line I have an issue with is the “not yet” delivery.
So, it’s blinded love for me, but not for you or anyone else who liked the ST?
I’m not struggling. I got the entire EU, hundreds of books and comics, a far better story than what Disney gave.
The digital release looks great but the upcoming 4K disc is supposedly reference quality.
https://thedigitalbits.com/item/star-wars-the-rise-of-skywalker-uhd
Amazon fire has the 4K release
Yes I have the 4K digital release too but the upcoming disc will look even better (and it will come with its own digital code.) Just sayin' in case you wanted to wait. I obviously didn't, lol.
punisher1974
Super Freak
I think Khev don't what to put in the effort as nothing he is going to say will change anyone's minds. Ducky already has stated that he has no issues with the acting.. other then little Anakin and AOTC Anakin..
If you want a complete take down of the PT I say just put the PT films in and hit play..
I never said the PT ruined my Childhood... It did however ruin the main villain of SW and SW as a whole for me. TROS actually helped with my enjoyment of the two ST films and the PT films...
The age defense is your blinded love for the PT.. And that is fine.. I still love The Black Hole, Orca, and Tron
Obviously you have not read what we all have been saying... We got a wrap up.. We all were very happy with how the film ended and the path our heroes ended up on.. Those that don't like TROS are the ones that are struggling.
Your right on age defense for a lot of people. I love the Black Hole, Tron, and Saturn 3 and Flash Gordon. All guilty pleasures.
jye4ever
Broke and happy
Wait what is this about ROTJ outtakes being used in TROS!
That was ROTJ footage!
I thought that was new footage made to look like the OT era.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
That was ROTJ footage!
I thought that was new footage made to look like the OT era.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
See there you go... What you see as great, I see as awful. You don't get how I can like the TROS.I cant understand how you can see no issues with that scene.. Let alone rank Palps performance higher then Luke's..
Maybe my nostalgia for Luke's "no" prevents me from seeing issues with it just like yours does for the Emperors? IDK.
The “goofy” back and forth was a ploy from Palpatine to make Anakin buy into the Jedi being traitors. I don’t see anything wrong with the delivery and Mace was right, Palpatine was too dangerous to be kept alive. Palpatine’s “I’m too weak... can’t hold it... too weak” lines were to get Anakin to step in.
Like I said, only line I have an issue with is the “not yet” delivery.
.
Oh I know why it was done.. But I think its delivered poorly and cut poorly... It comes across as goofy not dramatic.
But you like it..
Nothing wrong with that.
Last edited:
Which footage? Are you talking about young Leia's face for the Jedi Training sequence?
jye4ever
Broke and happy
I?m guessing that is what the Digitalbits review is referring to which is just baffling to me because that wasn?t ROTJ outtakes......right....or was it!
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
They inserted this shot of Fisher over Billie Lourd's face:
Then they used an ESB shot of Mark Hamill's face on Dagobah for younger Luke in that same scene.
Then they used an ESB shot of Mark Hamill's face on Dagobah for younger Luke in that same scene.
jye4ever
Broke and happy
Oh ok that I knew but he made it sound like a bigger outtake was used I was like where lol
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Yeah it's cool that for both young and old Leia's face it's all real Carrie footage and never CGI.
punisher1974
Super Freak
I did like that flashback scene. Too bad we never had a movie in that time period.
They inserted this shot of Fisher over Billie Lourd's face:
Then they used an ESB shot of Mark Hamill's face on Dagobah for younger Luke in that same scene.
View attachment 481372
They should have hired Jye to do the photoshop - it would have been more convincing.
That scene had such a fake look to me. I also couldn't understand why they were both wearing a-wing helmets.
ironwez20
Super Freak
- Joined
- Nov 17, 2008
- Messages
- 27,922
- Reaction score
- 5,941
I think Khev don't what to put in the effort as nothing he is going to say will change anyone's minds. Ducky already has stated that he has no issues with the acting.. other then little Anakin and AOTC Anakin..
If you want a complete take down of the PT I say just put the PT films in and hit play..
I never said the PT ruined my Childhood... It did however ruin the main villain of SW and SW as a whole for me. TROS actually helped with my enjoyment of the two ST films and the PT films...
The age defense is your blinded love for the PT.. And that is fine.. I still love The Black Hole, Orca, and Tron
Obviously you have not read what we all have been saying... We got a wrap up.. We all were very happy with how the film ended and the path our heroes ended up on.. Those that don't like TROS are the ones that are struggling.
I think you guys just don?t have a defense tbh. It?s just. PT bad. ST brought everything together
Similar threads
