There are two books that take place during the Clone Wars that deals with Force Healing and Bacta and the likes. Pretty cool cross between science fiction and medical practices. But even in those books, you couldn't bring someone back. EU didn't go that far.
Again I don't like either.. Its not a deal breaker but It just causes too many issues for all the films that came before it.
Now you can create your own head canon for this. That's part of the fun of SW... Its just a power I don't like the jedi having.
Did Rey pull it from her ass or did she mind rape someone for that info?
I assume she read the books.. It shows her doing so.
I think a better explanation could have ben that she felt lead by the force. But she should have said as much.
It's not dumb. I've explained this multiple times already. Google "Broken Heart Syndrome." It is a real thing. You ever hear news stories about old couples dying within hours to days of one another? You ever felt extreme distress? It is a physical reaction. A very real one at that.
Khev covered about all the other issues you have when in that state of emotional distress.
I don't like it. Never have never will
Pure conjecture out of thin air. Based on a narrative from Disney who tries to discredit the Jedi Order in their weak attempt at destroying PT lore.
Actually no... The Jedi order is shown to be problematic throughout the entire PT. Qui Gon has issues with them. Bad decision making and dogmatic practice helped lead to the fall of Anakin and the Jedi. This is shown in TCW also.
I bet Anakin does not fall to the dark side if Qui Gon was training him the whole time... Qui Gon new the Jedi order had issues and was always pushing back (According to Obi wan)
Just stop with the retconning. We all know those lines had no reference to the ST.
SW is one big Retcon
It all started with ESB
I don't have a problem with force healing... to a certain extent. That extent being saving someone from clear death or bringing them back.
Like I said... I have issues with both... It cause problems with the films either way... I don't care if it came from TROS or the EU.. It creates unanswerable questions...
At least with Rey and Ben I can try and explain it away with them being a Dyad.. If just any ol Jedi can do it then that creates all the same problems that you say bringing people back to life does.
That Dyad thing is the dumbest thing to exist in Star Wars lore for me. It makes no sense why those two are connected.
Makes no sense why Anakin was born a virgin birth either.. But I role with it.
You guys still bash the PT 20 years later yet you tell me to let go of a movie that released a few months ago? Are you serious?
good point
Please show me where Vader tried to kill Luke after he knew Luke was his son.
Please show me where Vader straight up tortured Luke, mind raped Luke, tried to run Luke over, and tried to kill him on multiple occasions.
How about killing Ben (as luke saw it), torturing his friends, carbon freezing his best friend ad handing him over to Jabba the hutt, destroying a planet, killing his best friend (Biggs) cutting off his hand, and worst of all trying to get him to betray everything he is by turning him to the dark side.
Rey and Kylo relationship is beyond demented. It's f'd up.
Meh.. One Kiss... I agree it was dumb.. Maybe it was just a big thank you for bringing her back from the dead
Please show me where Anakin tried to Kill Padme. Please show me where Anakin striaght up tortured Padme, mind raped her, tried to run her over, and tried to kill her on multiple occassions.
Did Kylo ever try to really kill her until maybe the final duel... I think it was apparent that he was just always trying to get her too come to the dark side. Even the "Run her over" bit.. I think he knew she could take care of herself. He wanted her to see her power.. He says as much.
My comment about Padme is that she was a very mature woman.. Hell she was the leader of Naboo at 16.. Anakin was a weird teenager period... So for them to fall in love the way they did always felt uncomfortable and creepy. It was a failure of Lucas's part for sure.
But I am not a fan of the Kylo / Rey attempted relationship.. It was forced in for sure.. Unless its a kiss of thanks
No, when Padme found out about Anakin, her heart literally couldn't take it and she died from shock and distress.
Nah.. She died form poor writing
Leia gets to kill her abuser. Rey gets to marry hers. Disgusting beyond belief.
Hey Rey dished it out as much as she took it. She mind raped right back, left him beaten and scared in their first duel, caused him to wreck a tie in a crash tht could have killed him... Rey didn't allow herself to be a victim.
She wanted Kylo to turn. She thought she could turn him. She saw goodness in him. She saw darkness in herself and probably could identify with him and she understood why her turned to the dark side in the first place..
Now does all of the this justify a romantic kiss... Nope.. I didn't like it when I saw it in the theaters.. more because it felt forced and came out of nowhere. But I thought the ST did a pretty good job of showing there was a connection between the two.
You were saying a Dyad should be Luke and Leia.. I was saying story wise it was more interesting to have it be two people on opposite sides of the force. You stated that it should not have been someone like Rey who was trash throw away desert baby,... I was making the comparison of story wise Anakin was a throw away slave child.. It the whole "Place you least likely expect" plot point.
It's funny, when Khev made a comment about the abuse Jake Llyod and Ahmed Best suffered at the hands of PT haters, he had the audacity to blame the actors. Where were you when that went overboard? Laughing with Jye?
I don't remember that.. I don't follow everything.. I guess we all owe an apology to Kelly Marie Tran also..
You been bashing on Daisy Ridley's looks...
I don't know what to say about Ahmed Best.. I don't know what his issues were
Jake Lloyd. His troubles were being bullied at school with kids making lightsaber noises at him and metal health issues after his sister died.
I never called you guys deranged for liking the ST, but you call me deranged for hating it?
Everything they added to Star Wars in the ST is complete utter **** and people chow down on it. The dyad was a joke and some 50 Shades of Grey/Twilight level Tumblr loving freaky **** just to prop up Mary Rey Sue into another level.
Comments like this come across as a true case of STDS
Is that why those same critics gave it the worse review per RT in Star Wars history?
I have no idea... I tend to watch YouTube critics whose opinions I value.. Some of them were not crazy about it but said it was still very Star Warsy
As for being worst reviewed.. Meh.. I don't care. The Thing was HATED by critics when that came out..
I only really care about one critic.. Me
The Star Wars universe that I loved and put thousands of dollars and thousands of hours into was destroyed.
Nah.. Simply ignore the ST. As for the EU being uncanonized... Well You should have known it was all fan fiction to begin with
Give it 20 years time and get back to me.
View attachment 483028
ST is more cartoony. Second panel looks like it belongs in a PS2 video game.
One shot is what you go after
Do you really want us to start posting cartoon shots from the PT.. We will be here all week
Having said that.. The PT was cutting edge at the time... Some of it looked bad back then but some of it still looks amazing today.
I imagine Ragnarok Thor saying I mind raped her it was a mutual mind raping.
