My big issue with KOTCS was the monkey/vine swinging and the nut shot stuff. The rest I rolled with pretty easy.
Bad pacing, CGI, John Hurt wasted on silly character and Marion finding mortal danger hilarious were my problems with it. I could deal with fridge-nuking and Aliens and giant spaceships just fine. The early motorbike chase was brilliant and Shia was fine, I don't understand why people single him out. An older Shortround-type character, whats the problem?