Will share a few thoughts. IMHO, Michelle Hurd does a poor job representing an effective message to the general public. In a previous video above with Breaking Points, where Hurd and Susan Sarandon talk about "donating money" to the cause is simply beyond the pale. No one is going to believe that Sarandon needs money donated to her. Hurd just wrapped up 28 episodes and 3 seasons of Picard. I recognize that they are inferring needing help for the many nameless faceless non-brand name performers in the industry, but the perception won't lean that way. It just lends more into the standard viewpoint of many regular working class people that Hollywood actors are just outright narcissists and out of touch with reality. ( I can attest from extensive personal experience that the many are totally in this zone)
If you observe Hurd in interviews, if it goes long enough, she keeps bringing the conversation back to herself. What she lost, her opportunities, what was taken from her, what she didn't get. That's not going to get the general public on your side. Everyone understands there is an implicit "class system" in the entire industry, but when you are in a major labor war, it's not a great idea to remind people of it all the time when you drive activism.
This is my viewpoint, no one needs to share it, while Hurd is bringing up some fair points, she does it in the way that offers and elicits absolutely zero empathy. Which leads into another issue
This area of discussion is a little more controversial, but relevant here. This is a short clip of Joe Rogan and Matthew McConaughey. Now MM is A list, so he can't be cancelled, but most actors couldn't say these things in public without massive retaliation within the industry at some point. I'm not really here to focus on what MM says about religion, but more of his point that Hollywood has created a lot of "product" of late that has alienated major cross sections of it's potential audience and often what will be perceived, in his words, as a "condescending" tone. If you are in a labor fight, and you want the public on your side, what happens to the half of the general American viewing audience already feel marginalized and insulted by you?
Can we just have an honest accounting of this here? So avoiding the obvious political angle, which is evident at this point in splitting the general audience, and we don't have to go much further there, but what about parents in general? Also men in general? There is a lot of stuff that many men see as misandrist in modern Hollywood. So why should they support this strike? Also many parents, of all kinds of backgrounds, are NOT happy with some of the "product" coming out ( I can't even call them films anymore) that lean into issues that they don't want their kids to be exposed to at this point or feel it should be left to parents inside their own homes. And then there are a few specific things that MM discusses.
So, I'm less invested in the specifics of each cross section, as much as you can't keep telling people that if they don't like your "product", that they shouldn't watch and go shove off, engage that as a form of "shock marketing", then desperately ask them to come back once you are on strike. Again, that just further pushes a very negative perception and image of major Hollywood players as full blown sociopaths that are neck deep in their self absorption and only desire to gaslight the general public.
But here's the thing. That person scraping by at 20K a year, let's hear from them. Why not put a human working class face on some real issues in the industry? But for Sarandon and Hurd, those are just cannon fodder as a means to an end. Why lose their virtue signaling opportunities otherwise?
Two things can be true at the same time. On one hand, the major power brokers are too punitive on a large share of working class people in the industry. Even the mob didn't break people's hands ( i.e. how can every day people pay you if they can't work because you maimed them?) On the other hand, there are elements of the "labor" side that didn't do very much to help their own cause. Going to war with your fans is egregiously stupid business. It makes no sense and all these chicken are coming home to roost now.
But we see this in our small hobby too. Great artists are often deficient businesspeople. Not all, but sometimes it looks like a bit too many.
There are many genuinely hard working, decent and good people in the industry. Many often unheralded. But I don't think they are being well represented here in this fight.