Monk said:And I would be one of them.
Millar's take on Cap (mirrored in the regular universe by Ed Brubaker) as a harder-edged soldier who actually killed a lot of guys during WWII (and continues to kill the bad guys today, as necessary) is a much more believable version of the character than the "let's just knock out an army of Nazis with a shield" version that we had to naively swallow for years. He's a super soldier, not a super-consciencious objector.
He's a superhero so I don't mind him not killing for the most part. Superman doesn't kill, Batman doesn't, Spider-Man doesn't, heck I think even the Hulk doesn't. Part of the gig. But the main thing I don't like about Ultimates Cap is just his personality. Seems like kind of a punk. I like the classic all-American boy scout variety (who still kicks the crap out of any bad guys in his path.) Plus the Ultimates version doesn't ever seem to throw his shield. Pass.
And, again, my vote goes to Cole Hauser as the best option for a Captain America actor in the movie.
Interesting. I think the casting for Cap would be among the hardest to choose properly. Based on previous roles Hauser could definitely pull off the attitude of the Ultimates version.