OK. Just for you, and you alone I'll try to list everything I liked in BvS. Keep in mind I've only seen it once.
The musical score(mostly). It worked in the context of the film for me.
Death of Bruce's parents. Best visualization of that moment I've seen. If you're going to introduce a new Batman then you have to show what made him. It's that moment that stops Bruce from being a child and turns him into a force of rage and vengeance.
The chaos of the attack on Metropolis. Not necessarily the whole thing but showing it from the ground level gave it new meaning. And the shot of Superman and Zod battling reminded me so much of Miracleman fighting Kid Miracleman it made me crack a smile.
Superman's entrance in the Africa scene. The sonic booms and seeing him fly in from the distance was beautiful.
Cavill as Clark. Something about him as Clark just speaks to me. He's not corny or goofy and even though he's so serious I see that earnestness in him that draws me to Superman as a character.
The scene from the trailer between Clark and Bruce(before they are interrupted)
Gal Gadot's lips and accent
There have been complaints about the cities not having character but I liked the realism of how they felt.
Most of Superman's flying scenes.
Batman warehouse.
Lens flares. Spielberg, JJ, Bay, I don't care who does them I like to see them.
Oh, Perry White. He totally felt like a real newspaper editor in today's world.
Affleck's build. Reminded me of that Alex Ross Bruce Wayne.
And that's about all I can think of.