From a financial perspective maybe, not filmmaking. Financially both films were disappointments, the original only getting out of its hole after years of home video and becoming a classic through reissues and people who study film. 2049 will have the same fate I believe: eventually it will recoup its cost.
And honestly that doesn't matter except films like it getting studios to back them. 2049 was made and done. It's future success will be determined by word of mouth and film fans making their friends watch it. It's not a look at "what not to do" but a look at "what intellectual and cerebral science fiction looks like" and "why great movies fail: the decline of the human braint"
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk