The first works because of :
Or quite simply put. Bruce.
And because shock value was differant in the 80s. We never saw something like Evil Dead become so mainstream at that time.
Today the gore is meaningless. The 80s did a great job of grindhouse expliotation and the early 2000's films took it to the next level with Saw and Hostel. Thanks to those series, today's audiences have seen everything from graphic child murder to genitals cut off and fed to animals. It's retarded it's come to that for several reasons most notably it's ruined shock value. Shock value doesn't exist anymore and so this movie will never have a chance. We've all seen tons of movies where all the main characters die and humanity loses. Top it off with a story we all already know and no interesting actors to draw us in and all you're doing is refining the effects of the original if you can even call it refinement.
This is the very definition of a torture porn, zero orginality, zero story and acting, realistic as possible graphic violence. And it will in no way bring a new generation of younger viewers into the fan fold, the young kids who actually like this movie will think Bruce's version is retarded.
Taking it to broadway is brilliant, remaking it like this is nothing but a waste of money.
has nothing to do with shock value....its called desensitization,which is defined as the diminished emotional responsiveness to a negative or aversive stimulus after repeated exposure to it