Re: Hot Toys – MMS183 - The Dark Knight Rises: Bane Collectible Figure
In some way, I actually agree with DiFabio regarding Batman's character arc. It wasn't a big deal for me, but at the same time, the start of TDKR practically rendered the point of TDK's ending moot. In TDK, Batman was described as the only one who "could take it", the one who was willing to make sacrifices. I don't mind the idea that "anyone can be a hero" but the fact that they established a different tone in TDK and went back on their word through TDKR.... the inconsistency kinda killed it. In that regard, I can definitely understand DiFabio's sentiment as I honestly felt the same way.
Now personally, I thought the ending of TDKR was great (Bruce actually moving with his life), but the message that "anyone can be a hero", and the passing of Batman's legacy left me a bit sour. It didn't help that Blake didn't even feel primed or convincing enough to be a suitable replacement considering his impulsive tone and attitude throughout the film (he felt more like the revived Jason Todd than **** Grayson or even Tim Drake which is never a good thing).
As for the villains, I honestly love what they did with Bane, even as a "protectah". It worked, he was a twisted version of what would've been Bruce's role had he actually joined Ra's Al Ghul's cause. His very creation is SPECIFICALLY catered to Batman (I really don't get why anyone feels the need to bring in JLA here considering how utterly irrelevant it is to his character role). Now my main issue? Talia. The idea of the twist wasn't bad by any means, but whatever weight or expectations Nolan had planned for that twist was barely felt as Talia had so little characterization to make her distinct or even interesting enough to actually warrant such a half-hearted reveal in the end. I felt that despite the good character-construction that Nolan had built for Bane (yes that includes his caring side in relation to Talia), I thought that Talia's weak characterization greatly undermined his role and cause. What was initially set up to be a twisted version of Ra's Al Ghul's goal (Bane's vendetta against Bruce, instigating tyranny etc), turned out to be a retread of the exact same goal with Talia's lack of further elaboration on her motives.
The movie definitely had problems, huge problems, even beyond the characterization and the plot (some questionable cinematography and portrayal of time lapses etc.) Personally the main thing that saved it for me was Bane's overall character and Bruce's fate in the ending, but otherwise even I felt like the movie fell short in delivering something far more meaningful than what it gave us.