I understand the criticisms and frankly it is par for the course on here regardless of how good he looks. The super close up shots offer a lot of details or lack there of for some to critique but I have to say that when I walked up to the case on Wednesday Preview night I literally said "Holy Sh!#, look at all this cool stuff... and look at Luke!"
In person, through glass, I thought he looked pretty damn good. And then to have the Death Star Trooper, Death Star Gunner, Power Droid, and the Droid Duo right below him along with both versions of Rey, Finn, et all. It was pretty awesome. The only thing that took me back in that case was 3PO... he looked king of "soft" or something.
I would buy this look in second if he had one freaking line in the movie. His role was almost a post-credit reveal al la Marvel so I would rather wait and see Ep. IIIV and then get that one or come back to this one if for some reason I don't like the costume as much. That being said when the production piece comes out and it looks awesome (which I certainly hope it does), I may break down. I thought he looked pretty cool.
I have too many Lukes on the shelf as it is but at least this one actually looks different due to age, the others are really too close.