Good post
I do agree that the WS/AoU is closer in certain lighting conditions / certain poses, but not enough to say it blows the A1 Sculpt out of the water, and that's basically my main beef heh.
- After this amount of time one of them absoltuely should be. It should be a case of the A1 was really kool at the time, but boy oh boy how about that AoU Sculpt!?"
Instead, neither really does ScarJo any justice and so it comes down to the overall look and I completely agree that the A1 BW sculpt still gets my vote because it doesn't look utterly lifeless and is more animate.
I had my eye on the WS BW for some time, even put out a wanted request on the board (prior to pre-ordering the AoU), it's not that I feel it's a terrible piece, because it isn't - I just think for the price, and considering how some of the other sculpts are turning out, it's about time hot toys just scrap the WS foundation and go-again with a brand new sculpt.
It's mostly frustraition on my part, as there can't be that many more ScarJo BW appearances, and it would be nice to have at least
one awesome ScarJo sculpt (& figure) before she hangs up her batons and glock 26's for good.