generalgrevious
Super Freak
I just picked up the tarkin /vader chest box to use on mine. wonder which version is better RO VI or V2
I just picked up the tarkin /vader chest box to use on mine. wonder which version is better RO VI or V2
I just picked up the tarkin /vader chest box to use on mine. wonder which version is better RO VI or V2
This has been talked about ad nauseum especially in the last 6 pages but...
Its a split decision: some like the more accurate size of the RO/v2 and some like the more accurate looking v1.
RO/v2 = more accurate size, but the buttons and coin slots are too small and spaced out (to put it simply)
v1 = undersized, but the layout of the buttons and slots is more accurate looking
Most settle on the v1 that is undersized but looks correct.
I just picked up the tarkin /vader chest box to use on mine. wonder which version is better RO VI or V2
I don't know that`s why I ask the question. and ask which do folks like the most.
Agreed.. And only to add the RO/v2 has weathering detail, the v1 does not and is clean.
Honestly, go with whichever looks best to you. For myself, personally, I love the V1 one.
Dude, I love talking this vader. This is the most fun I've had with any attempt at modding a figure ever. I learned a lot with this guy. And still am. Ask away.
very true, but an easy fix with some silver paint and a micro brush or even q-tip minus the cotton. I think I am going to move the silver dots from v2 to the v1 I have. v2 (r1) looks odd to me.
Yeah, those pics several pages back were great. Never even realized the silver dots were accurate to ANH Vader's chest straps. I was confused why they added them to the Tarkin v2. But still doesn't make sense why they added it to the belt, or gave him the wrong lightsaber which is the most confusing of all since it is correct on the v1.. Oddest choice of all.
How are the silver dots attached to the v2 chest plate? they just glued on and not punched through?
I just picked up the tarkin /vader chest box to use on mine. wonder which version is better RO VI or V2
I keep reading comments about the v1 chest box being undersized. Even if it is undersized, it's by such a minuscule amount that I'm really surprised that it keeps getting brought up here. So, I decided to take some photos for comparison to the actual movie Vader. As usual with Vader, I prefer to work with photos where Prowse didn't have the cape on (this is really helpful when customizing/modifying Vader figures). I chose one that has already been posted in this thread.
The first side-by-side is comparing the HT v1 figure (only modification is RO gloves added). The red lines were for my own reference to scale the two images properly, but I left them in to demonstrate that the Vaders are scaled properly. You can see that the chest box isn't glaringly small on the figure. And, the only reason that you see more of the undersuit between the chest box and the belt is because of the poorly-designed pants and codpiece of the v1 figure. That can be remedied too (more on that in a minute).
View attachment 400496
This next pic shows some outlines that I created of the movie Vader's chest box. I then copied the exact same lines and imposed them over the figure's chest box. I think it lines up reasonably well. I didn't outline the edges of the box itself because it's too lost in shadows to be precise, but you can extrapolate from the lines used for the box components.
View attachment 400497
Lastly, I wanted to switch out the suit and codpiece to the Sideshow ESB/ROTJ ones in order to show how things can line up even more accurately (also swapped the chest/shoulder armor for a more weathered one, and swapped to a modified v1 belt). The chest box size is certainly not a glaring problem. And if you use the RO/v2 box, you'll have other issues with symmetry and spacing that might not be worth the perceived benefit of more accurate size.
View attachment 400498
Sorry for beating a dead horse about the chest box, but it gets brought up enough here that I thought I could lend some visual assistance to help people evaluate the v1 size (and overall accuracy).
Good job.
You know, if we didn't mention that the v1 box was smaller, then we get inundated with people posting side by sides of the two HT boxes to prove the v1 is smaller. That cycle has blown past a number of times. I imagine it will begin again now.
It happens when people's preference is driven by OCD.
See -- the OCD is strong with this group. I was waiting for Talibane.
Someone can always pull a picture as evidence that shows things the way they see it.
At the end of the day, you just gotta go with what looks right to you. I've seen so many people talk about one thing or another that's incorrect and inaccurate, and then you see their figure and there's so much other stuff wrong they don't notice that you just have to throw up your hands.
See -- the OCD is strong with this group. I was waiting for Talibane.
Someone can always pull a picture as evidence that shows things the way they see it.
At the end of the day, you just gotta go with what looks right to you. I've seen so many people talk about one thing or another that's incorrect and inaccurate, and then you see their figure and there's so much other stuff wrong they don't notice that you just have to throw up your hands.
Might as well go with it's not the correct shade of black either. And the green and red dials are not the correct shade. And the grey dials are too light of a grey.
It's only because I'm working on a ANH and ESB bash that I'm super-OCD on Vader.
Enter your email address to join: