It's funny that people keep blaming Faramir. Makes me wonder if they were even really LOTR fans/collectors in the first place.
If he'd come out perfect, I seriously doubt people would've bailed on the line. Likewise, he'd have gone unmentioned had we gotten an Uruk-Hai or an Orc or Saruroman. So to keep bringing that up is benign. Naturally, like pretty much all the other lines, true fans, if not interested, would've just skipped Faramir and picked up the others. But the fact that Gandalf and the Hobbits, arguably some of Sideshow's BEST work in 1:6, were left rotting on the website (they're long sold out now but for entirely different reasons so don't go there
) backs up the ADD/Bandwagon thoughts and semi-justifies Sideshow's abandonment. I think it was a combination of only three things and in this order: Sideshow's poor release schedule, a lack of villains and ADD fans.