ronri
Super Freak
- Joined
- Sep 15, 2012
- Messages
- 2,524
- Reaction score
- 27
As time goes by and I replay PW, I've learned to like pretty much everything about it, I now like Hayter's voice too, precisely because it sounds cartoonish, and that's exactly the tone of Peace Walker, I've outgrown maturity and seriousness and I can enjoy ridiculous stuff.
Having said that, I agree, that voice doesn't work with this new darker tone, and Snake should not sound like that considering Solid is much younger in the MG games, but I feel it would strip most of the character's personality if Hayter doesn't do the voice himself, it would be a lot harder for me to accept than Kiefer for BB.
I really can't imagine anyone else voicing the character, it would have to be almost an impersonation, sort of like what Roger Craig Smith did in Arkham Origins, at times he really strives at a younger Conroy.
See, I didn't mind his work in PW during the more cartoonish moments or any of the action "scenes" (PW just kinda has that derpy charm to it). It was when it got to the more solemn/serious moments that required a lot more flexibility in the tone/emotions that I felt his voice took a nosedive and sounded too gravelly. Half the time it sounded too simple or exaggerated that it almost killed some of the more serious scenes for me.
That said, I agree. I can stomach Kiefer as BB based on the various reasons I've stated above but it would be a true loss if Solid Snake comes back without Hayter's voice. If they get a new VA it should be as good as the ones like Troy Baker or Roger Craig Smith's work from Arkham Origins.