Official 1/6th Darth Vader Thread

Collector Freaks Forum

Help Support Collector Freaks Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
Status
Not open for further replies.
I'm referring to the A-symettricall armor and mask we see at the end of the film, not Hayden. Why the Horror?

You mean symetrical right?, besides that..the helmet design was also changed quite a bit from the OT.
 
Really?!! Thats fast. Is he good?:)

See below:

5wmdf9.gif
 
Not surprising that they'd release the others... Vader is key, and its hard to get too much of him.
 
I'm referring to the A-symettricall armor and mask we see at the end of the film, not Hayden. Why the Horror?

Because the ROTS Vader costume represents a lot of what is wrong about the prequels:

1 - No sense of visual continuity or respect for the aesthetic of the OT (the transition from that to the one in ANH is laughable)

2 - Contrived revisionism ("instead of going with what we already did, let's make the helmet symmetrical and everything all black... just because we can! Also, while we're at it... let's make the lightsabers different too, even though that's supposed to be the same one Obi-Wan hands to Luke in ANH.") :rolleyes:

3 - It just doesn't look right. The symmetrical look of the new helmet loses a lot of the character and mystique that the OT Vader image has (especially that of ANH).

4 - "Noooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo!!!!!!"
 
Because the ROTS Vader costume represents a lot of what is wrong about the prequels:

1 - No sense of visual continuity or respect for the aesthetic of the OT (the transition from that to the one in ANH is laughable)

2 - Contrived revisionism ("instead of going with what we already did, let's make the helmet symmetrical and everything all black... just because we can! Also, while we're at it... let's make the lightsabers different too, even though that's supposed to be the same one Obi-Wan hands to Luke in ANH.") :rolleyes:

3 - It just doesn't look right. The symmetrical look of the new helmet loses a lot of the character and mystique that the OT Vader image has (especially that of ANH).

4 - "Noooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo!!!!!!"

I suppose those are all valid points, but none of them really bother me.
I think the only aspect that makes me raise an eyebrow is the lack of continuity, but that's about it.
And even so, Vader's appearance changed throughout the OT, what's the problem of having it different in ROTS?
And why shouldn't they make Vader's symmetrical? The fact that they couldn't get it right the first time around doesn't mean they have to keep making it wrong time and again... As for it being all black, why not? It was painted in different tones just to make it photograph better, not because it necessarily had to look that way. So now they can make it look good even if it's all black, good for them!
As for the "noooooo", I've no problem with it. It's still a young, confused Anakin/Vader in there. Should he become all calm and composed all of a sudden? :rolleyes:
 
I have no problem with how Vader looks at the end of ROTS honestly. I'll get that version.
 
I have no problem with how Vader looks at the end of ROTS honestly. I'll get that version.

Yeah, I have no problem with how he looks in ROTS either but that one is a very low 4th on the list of needed 1/6 Vaders for me.
 
And even so, Vader's appearance changed throughout the OT, what's the problem of having it different in ROTS
Because it looks/sounds much more advanced than the one he wears in the film that takes place 20 years later?

If anything, it should have looked like a prototype (maybe like the McQuarrie designs) or at least much more like the ANH visage. They just dropped the ball terribly here, imho. It makes no sense from a visual continuity standpoint at all.

That said, I'll probably buy one if SSC makes it just to have one of each of the Vader representations (because they are all different). It just better come AFTER all of the OT ones.
 
The films are supposed to be viewed as films, not frame by frame stills.
Vader is still Vader.
Anakin's lightsaber is still Anakin's lightsaber.
Once you've seen the films one time, the mystique is already gone. You know that Anakin is Vader and Luke is his son and what he looks like and how he got there.
It's not perfect, thats what makes it star wars.
 
Because it looks/sounds much more advanced than the one he wears in the film that takes place 20 years later?

If anything, it should have looked like a prototype (maybe like the McQuarrie designs) or at least much more like the ANH visage. They just dropped the ball terribly here, imho.

I agree that maybe a McQuarrie style mask/helmet Vader should have been in ROTS. But I guess Lucas just wanted to go w/the original well close to the original...:rolleyes::D
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top