demorathis
Super Freak
- Joined
- Sep 14, 2009
- Messages
- 1,850
- Reaction score
- 8
I agree with a couple caveats; Don't cut Jar Jar out, just cut his screen time. Just like you suggested for the pod race...it was wayy too long.
I got a chance to see AOTC in Imax and it was great because due to the reel size, they had to re-edit the movie cutting many of the bad sappy love scenes out. Best thing they could've done for that movie. The pacing was better. The scenes were more cohesive and a lot of the bad acting was cut. Made for a much better movie.
ROTS...can't agree more.
These movies weren't great but they were good. GL just needed someone to help steer the boat. I personally think he was wayyy too close to the projects and likely had no subjective opinions to refine his ideals. I mean, if you worked for Lucas, whose gonna be the guy in the room that says,"Uhhhhhh...I don't get it?" Hard to say to this guy who has had more movie success than all the guys working for him combined that you took some very talented actors and turned them into one dimensional mannequins?
I would've loved it if Jar Jars highsjinks was done in the background during other moments...instead of in the spotlight...it could've been done in such a way that makes him more lovable And cut majority of his lines if not all so he's just physical background if-you-pay-attention-comic-relief-for-the-bored-or eagle eyed...like Easter egg humor .... One small thing along those lines was when the pit droid kicked him in the nuts, since it was so brief and a big deal wasn't made of it