Re: Tobey Maguire VS Andrew Garfield
I have to go with Andrew Garfield. I liked his wit and I think his personality and acting style mirrored Peter Parker much more than Tobey. Not saying that Tobey did a bad job, he did a GREAT job, just not better than Garfield. Plus, Tobey's monotone voice bugs me at times. Whenever I think of Tobey, I think of his meek, monotone voice and how I struggle to believe his acting at times.
I also like that Amazing Spidey focuses on Spidey's high school days as opposed to Raimi's Spider-man that basically skips to college soon after he becomes Spider-man.
If you ever read Ultimate Spider-man, you'll instantly be able to see how Garfield is an almost exact mirror of that version of Spider-man.