1/6 1/6 Hot Toys - MMS 452 - Star Wars: Episode V ESB - Darth Vader

Collector Freaks Forum

Help Support Collector Freaks Forum:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.
And a comparison with my custom..

View attachment 429641

This is the comparison I was hoping to be able to see. Thank you for posting this!

When I scroll your photo so that the helmets are off the screen, the HT Vader actually looks quite good. But then when I scroll back up and see the difference in the helmets . . . :horror That HT ESB mouth is something I just can't get over.

Still love that custom. Continues to look great!

Looking great. The helmet on the ESB Vader always seems to sit a bit too low, whereas the RO and ANH Vaders either side in Matrix's pic have the helmets sitting more clear of the shoulders.

I think it's the angle/orientation of the dome that makes it seem that way. The mask itself looks to be resting properly over the shoulder armor. In fact, if anything, there might be more space than needed between the bottom of the neck and the top of the chest box.

I'm surprised that nobody has tried to do something to either swap domes, or re-orient the ESB one so that it doesn't angle so far down at the back.
 
Here are some photos I took of my ESB Vader.
8e04244d6fd8b2e6a7a2ddb956dce1e5.jpg
c963bd96e49955f42bb1580850284462.jpg
c98c1fcdd678477b8e06b557054893ab.jpg



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
This is the comparison I was hoping to be able to see. Thank you for posting this!

When I scroll your photo so that the helmets are off the screen, the HT Vader actually looks quite good. But then when I scroll back up and see the difference in the helmets . . . :horror That HT ESB mouth is something I just can't get over.

Still love that custom. Continues to look great!

Once the lil' button nose is fixed on the HT ESB facemask, the whole helmet comes together for me. It is quite rightly getting a lot of flack due to the "big mouth" issue (as well as the break in the tusk rails, downward pointing tusks, reveal brace greeblies being visible etc etc) but with the nose fixed and mods done, I actually think it's the best of the HT helmets side by side with the HT ANH/RO sculpt.

I still do think the Huricane/Kaiyodo route yields the most accurate look - I also have a HT ESB Vader as well as a custom Hurricane/Kaiyodo Vader, and I do think the custom helmet looks a bit better, even if the finish is better on the HT helmet.

I think it's the angle/orientation of the dome that makes it seem that way. The mask itself looks to be resting properly over the shoulder armor. In fact, if anything, there might be more space than needed between the bottom of the neck and the top of the chest box.

I'm surprised that nobody has tried to do something to either swap domes, or re-orient the ESB one so that it doesn't angle so far down at the back.

I think it might be that the ESB cape is pretty thick due to the layered fabrics and this "lifts" the shoulders a few more mm than the others. The RO cape is more like a stretchable lyrca material with a single layer so it not only thinner, it stretches slightly (its a VERY heavy fabric) which slightly thins it even more over the shoulder armor. Though I think the ANH cape is double fabric also - I never had that in-hand.

The HT ESB Vader always looks like the helmet needs to be raised by a few mm to me to compensate for the thicker cape.
 
R1 imo has the most accurate mouth size. Overall I prefer the HT esb, for all the details being there, finish and overall quality. Tho you can see the to me much inferior SS deluxe got a partial head reveal done without the tusk rail gaps. I still think they put those there on purpose as a nod to the suit up scene in episode III. Howard is a big prequel fan.

Thanks for posting the lineup
 
Looking great. What are the respective heights on your four Vaders, Matrix?



The helmet on the ESB Vader always seems to sit a bit too low, whereas the RO and ANH Vaders either side in Matrix's pic have the helmets sitting more clear of the shoulders.
I'll have to get the ruler out and measure them.
Nice Matrix! Excellent customs!

Wow that’s a fantastic custom that screams Vader
Thanks guys:duff
Should just junk the HT ESB and keep the ESB custom haha. The dome looks enormous on HT ESB
I'll be customizing the HT version..
...and they're back :lol

That custom esb Vader is amazing tho. What's the recipe?
Kaiyodo/SS deluxe mask,Kaiyodo shoulder/boot armor and boots,Hasbro titanium helmet,SS ANH suit,SS DELUXE chest box,belt/boxes and hilt,custom gloves and Rayon cape and tunic.
This is the comparison I was hoping to be able to see. Thank you for posting this!

When I scroll your photo so that the helmets are off the screen, the HT Vader actually looks quite good. But then when I scroll back up and see the difference in the helmets . . . :horror That HT ESB mouth is something I just can't get over.

Still love that custom. Continues to look great!



I think it's the angle/orientation of the dome that makes it seem that way. The mask itself looks to be resting properly over the shoulder armor. In fact, if anything, there might be more space than needed between the bottom of the neck and the top of the chest box.

I'm surprised that nobody has tried to do something to either swap domes, or re-orient the ESB one so that it doesn't angle so far down at the back.

The Empire mask is all kinds of wrong...tusks,mouth grill slope,cheek shape,eye shape,dept of eyes lens,small nose,short neck etc....it's all a complete mess and a disappointing step backwards from the ANH/R1 versions...which have issues too but are still more accurate.
 
I agree that the HT ESB Vader helmet is a disappointment overall - I'm still planning to see if I can fix stuff like the angle of the "teeth," the hideous gap/step in the tusk rail and the visible-from-the-front "reveal" greeblies (just lazy on HT's part) as well as sanding the two facemask "halves" to get them to sit closer together - but with a few mods it still can display pretty nicely. The slightly off cheek sculpts I'm just going to have to be okay with.

It does have some positives - for example they fixed the awful mesh pattern (behind teeth) the RO/ANH sculpt has, got rid of the slight "points" on the sides of the nose surround, and they didn't do yet another "plug" nose - for these, we should be thankful.:lol Overall, I like it better than the RO/ANH sculpt, though I haven't yet done all my many mods on that sculpt yet, so I guess I'm getting ahead of myself.

45184915772_2d1bf8718b_o.png


43422052040_6a2f3c0848_o.png



:clap Thanks so much for these comp pics you do.
 
My thought was to sand down the top half where it joins the bottom. Shouldn't be super hard to do and might make it look less long in the front
 
My thought was to sand down the top half where it joins the bottom. Shouldn't be super hard to do and might make it look less long in the front

Yeah, I'm planning to do the same, so it narrows the chin gap so the mouth triangle size reduces further.

You kinda forget just how many mods it takes to get the RO/ANH facemask to look good - this one may have more.:lol
 
I’m too lazy to multi quote all the things but I felt like making a few comments.

It’s not just the mouth slant that’s backwards on the kaiyodo mask. The whole mask is a mirror image of the real deal (the cheeks being an obvious example).

The deluxe Sideshow doesn’t have the reveal gap in the tusk tubes because they eliminated the entire front portion of the top tube and it looks awful.

I don’t know what some of y’all are on about the shape of the HT ESB cheeks and eyes being off? They look fine to me. While different, they’re not any more off than the ANH/R1 mask. And in some ways I think they’re better. (See below a comparison to an Efx full size mask, and I’m pretty sure the HT mask below has had the tusks and nose modded, but since we’re talking about cheeks and eyes here that shouldn’t matter)

As for the mouth, when properly lit, it’s really not nearly as wrong as many photos make it appear. I think the ROTJ style fat bottom lip combined with the tusk position really throw off some photos, but in hand (or with favorable lighting conditions) it’s not nearly as bad as some people say.


6sjhGdq.jpg
 
Back
Top