Funny, I watched the movie with a complete open mind yesterday, enjoyed it a lot, but still, I find that I share the opinion of another freak (can't remember who and too lazy to search) about the movie lacking "soul".
Somehow, I love almost everything, I even think the relationship between Lois and Clark was well portrayed, but I still think there is something missing, something that I can't really pinpoint...
Although the CG effects made e everything look so much better than the Donner flicks, I found MOS lacking that little spark of magic that left me with bewildered eyes when I was a kid. Maybe it's just nostalgia, but it felt like I was watching a whole lot of awesome effects, but all the time I kept wondering "where is the spirit"?
Maybe I was expecting too much, but in the end, I'm wondering if I didn't enjoy SR better than MOS.
HC was a great Superman, though, and once again, I liked it, but in the end, the story was pretty thin and I guess we'll have to wait the sequel to have real character development...