I think Naughty Dog is more than capable of handling MG. If anything, they can perhaps humanize Metal Gear again and bring some order to the chaotic story. Like Gaspar noted, Kojima is too melodramatic and in fact, that is a trait of Japanese developers that they put in their games. For being a "Western" style game, Metal Gear is too caught in its "Eastern" roots. There's drama in EVERYTHING when it doesn't have to be.
I look at Kojima as I do George Lucas. Kojima has enveloped Metal Gear into this "Star Wars"-like universe and created this entire mythology that is now being DAMAGED by its creator because he wants to tie everything together at once, going backwards and forwards and then back again and then forward again. He's not quite on Lucas-level yet, but he's getting there.
What Metal Gear needs now is a SIMPLE story. It needs a fresh start and it needs taking all those years of games and condensing it into a new and fresh history. "Ultimatize" it if you will like Marvel had done with their "Ultimate" series of comics (I'll fill you in if you don't know what I'm talking about), but this has got to end somewhere.
I'm excited for MGSV for the gameplay and it looks AWESOME. And I WANT to care about the story and I hope it's trim and done well, but knowing Kojima it will likely be more mess, and I'm prepared for that.
Well, the one thing to consider, is that Kojima's a Japanese man who's writing a war story on American soldiers. Just based on that alone, it becomes extremely tricky to relate to characters from a different cultural background. But, despite that, he was very well grounded in in his direction for MGS 1, which had a very "Westernized" feel in its storyline - and even though there was a giant mech and a cyborg ninja, it was a storyline that Americans and others in the West could relate to, because it reminded us of the action movies that we saw in cinemas. It's a stark contrast to what's been happening in recent years with MGS, as the plots have exceeded levels of ridiculousness with gratuitous amounts of sci-fi tech that shouldn't have existed in the 70s. In other words, MGS has gotten too "Japanese" for its own good.
It's pretty obvious that he has lost his way with this series and I don't think you're wrong to refer to him as the George Lucas of gaming. Honestly, I'd wish if MGS would just end, and have Platinum develop more futuristic games for MG Rising.
I think the remakes could work as a fresh start.
Not if the remakes are shown through Big Boss's perspective, with Snake as the main antagonist
