You guys are worrying me with your speculations! At least we'll have eye candy if anything. I was curious why you guys wanted another Solid Snake game, because I thought you'd worry about it watering down his story. I think you could get great stories, but the problem is working with the gameplay. Once you throw in bosses, it's going to be ridiculous. I wish Kojima would just make Metal Gear movies, so he'd be free to tell the story he wants. Well with the help of an editor.
Batman, Dragon Ball (Japanese only), Metal Gear Solid are my big geek fandoms! Although, I don't own a single piece of MGS merchandise other than the games.
1. MGS3- It's been my favorite game for the past 10 years. I know MGSV will dethrone it gameplay-wise, but I don't know about the story. The story is so dumb, but it's extremely self-aware. THE BOX IS HIS DESTINY! I don't know how any game will top those last two hours for me. It's the only game that I've ever felt emotional over. Since Big Boss wasn't as a defined character as Solid Snake, I felt like I was him. Being that it's an interactive video game, that immerses me more. My only criticism is that I wished they would have developed the Cobra Unit more, because I love the idea of Big Boss defeating his pain, fear, death, fury, but not his sorrow. This was the game that introduced CQC, which is my favorite gaming mechanic. It just made boss fights so much fun, and it's a shame that when they expanded it in MGS4, they didn't give us much options to use it against bosses.
2. MGS- Best supporting cast, villains, and atmosphere. Unfortunately, I feel like the gameplay went downhill a bit after the opening, but it's still a good game. The elevator room and hellicarrier's level design is so good for stealth, and it's a shame they didn't expand on it that much as the game progressed. The game structure is very similar to the previous ones, which is probably what hurt this one a lot for me originally. I also don't feel like it controls very well, or at least, I do not feel like a cool super soldier. I don't think the combat is very good, and it's frustrating when they force you to use it. It's not cool when your gun shoots straight up in the air, when a guy is right in front of you. Once I get past the cringe-worthy dialogues (the laughs....I can't stand those cheesy laughs!), I love the story. Mighty props to introducing the Human Genome Project to a lot of teens.
3. MGS2- This has been my second favorite game of all time for years. However, I forgot there's a lot of stuff you got to weed through to get to the goods. Kojima really needed an editor. I always loved it though! It was the game that taught me as a teenager that I'm too trusting. Although I may have took it too far by wearing a tin foil hat for few years (kidding!), I learned not to be so trusting of the media influences. It's helped me a lot! Anyways, I love the gameplay and the music--maybe the best in the series!
4. MGS4- The game is beautiful! You have to turn your brain off at a lot of points, but man, Kojima out-did himself with the choreography. I don't know any game director that would want to put all that work into a split screen sequence like he did with the Ray fight/ Raiden vs Vamp. They knew that so many people would miss out on their hard-work making that scene, but they did it for immersion. I love when my heroes get beaten down, because that connects me to the character more. The reason I became a Batman fan as a child was because of the Knightfall storyline with Batman getting obliterated physically and emotionally. It just inspires me seeing them get back from it. The problem is that they weren't very respectful to Snake. If Kojima didn't want Snake to kill himself at the end, fine, but then don't make him pull the trigger. Did he miss? What the heck happened? Did he shoot a squirrel? That would make sense, but then they'd have to show that. Along with that, it seemed like Big Boss took the spot light away from Snake's final mission. I don't know. I still love the game. I've beaten it over 30 times, which is way more than any other numbered game. Oh and I love the soundtrack!
5. MGS PO- I haven't played this game in a long time, because I've been done with handhelds since God of War Ghost of Sparta (That killed that franchise for me, sadly). The story might not have been the greatest, but I loved the gameplay. When Gene makes my men kill eachother, it made me realize how attached I got to me team. I could really feel for Big Boss when he was screaming for Gene to stop, because I was doing the same thing! Oh and Calling to the Night is still my favorite MGS song!
5. MGS Ground Zeroes- It's a demo, but I loved it! It's the reason I know MGSV will have my favorite gameplay. It's still the only PS4 game that I've played, except the free ones in the trial. Outlast was good!
6. MGS PW- Next! It's not that enjoyable on the PS3, but I thought it was a great MGS game to have on the go for 5 or 10 minute bursts. David Hayter's "No, why won't it stop" line is one of my favorite performances by him, despite my criticism. He just needs the director to tell him to pull back a bit, because he is the voice of Snake.
7. Metal Gear Rising- The gameplay was great, but I don't like the aesthetic, characters, or the story.